So, if this is supposed to be Jesus, are you, bkaycee, saying that Jesus sinned?Psalm 69 is recognized by the Catholic Church as messianic. Is the Roman church also claiming Jesus was a sinner?
http://www.scripturecatholic.com/messianic_prophecies.html
I know you already responded to this, though some see it not, but if i may add that as far i know there is not official RC interpretation of this, and it is estimated that only a few verses of Scripture have beenb “infallibly” defined, while the doctrinal paramenters of RCs have much liberty
the Biblical norm is that seldom is all of a section prophetic in which a prophecy is found, and if v. 5 disallows v. 8 from speaking of Christ, then it would follow that v. 9 is also not prophetic of Christ, which explains why the subject was rejected by his brethren.
And thus Jn. 2:17, which quotes Ps. 69:a, cannot be prophetic of Christ either, though the same gospel also records that “His own received Him not,” “neither did His own brethren believe in Him.” (Jn. 1:11; 7:5)
Nor can Rm. 15:3, which quotes 69b as applying to Christ.
In addition, while Catholics lack the extensive Scripture commentaries of evangelical, the conservative Catholic Haydock commentary applies Ps. 69:8 to Christ as well, Ver. 9. Mother. This might be true with respect to some apostate Jews. But it was more fully accomplished in Christ, who was betrayed by Judas, &c. (Calmet) -— His own received him not, John i. (Berthier)