To: HarleyD
Ps. 69:8 is part of a a Messianic prophecy, (Ps. 69:9; Jn. 2:17) and is one of many evidences against this unnecessary, if not salvific, teaching of perpetual virginity, which requires a degree of special pleading if it is defended as being from Scripture, rather than oral Tradition. I think that Joseph showed the greater virtue is Mary remained a virgin, and while linguists can argue (http://www.theologyweb.com/campus/showthread.php?108759-Greek-quot-until-quot-In-Matt-1-25) whether heōs (till in Mt. 1:25 http://www.justforcatholics.org/a105.htm) or "adelphos" ("brethren in Mt.12:42) warrants either side, and against the normal denotation, but among other things perpetual virginity in marriage is contrary to the description of marriage that Jesus affirmed, (Gn. 2:24; Mt. 19:5) for you have leave without cleave in becoming one flesh (which oneness spiritually is also intercourse: Jn. 17:23) as well as being contrary to the apostolic instructions regarding celibacy within marriage. (1Cor. 7:5) In no place do we see anyone maintaining perpetual virginity in marriage, providing both were able, and Scripture says nothing about Mary being an exception, which is contrary to how exceptions in basic things are treated, and thus the virgin birth is clearly stated, as well as the sinless life of Christ. But autocracy allows men to teach for doctrines the traditions of men. If defending the above or any RC teaching, Catholics actually have much liberty to interpret the Bible to do so, however, this is not a salvific issue, and so i do not see it needing more extended debate.
111 posted on
06/13/2011 7:50:28 PM PDT by
daniel1212
( "Repent ye therefore, and be converted, that your sins may be blotted out," Acts 3:19)
To: daniel1212; HarleyD
...however, this is not a salvific issue, and so i do not see it needing more extended debate. I think you err in this respect. They moved outside Scripture to create these heresies (ever virgin and immaculate conception) and in doing so decided that tradition and their power of interpretation (their magisterium) are equals of Scripture. Moving away from Scripture as the rule of the faith has led them to preach a different gospel in which God is dependent upon their cooperation in His plan of salvation.
Now they worship Mary and bow down to idols of her.
134 posted on
06/13/2011 8:40:35 PM PDT by
wmfights
(If you want change support SenateConservatives.com)
To: daniel1212
for you have leave without cleave in becoming one flesh (which oneness spiritually is also intercourse: Jn. 17:23)Exactly...If Mary and Joseph did not have sexual relations, they were never married...
211 posted on
06/14/2011 9:55:26 AM PDT by
Iscool
(I don't understand all that I know...)
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson