Wow! Glad you could find the link.
I have to admit that the discussion on that thread is much more “high-brow” than what I’m used to seeing on the religion forum these days.
Yes, that was before FR purged a lot of the trad Catholics. They had a depth of knowledge that is often lost among us post-VII educated Catholics.
Fortunately, post-Summorum Pontificum, its no longer bad to be Trad.