From your page:
"But regardless, it speaks poorly of you to denigrate anothers faith. I wouldnt do it to someone who is of a Protestant denomination."
And yet, here you are doing it, not once but thrice.
he is reacting to hateful comments, he is not attacking the doctrines of a particular Protestant denomination. if X makes a hateful comment or lies about the Church and happens to be a Baptist, it is fair game to call out X for the comments, without attributing them to all Baptists. that is what IC is doing.
No. That is a mischaracterization unless you are claiming their “faith” is lying about the Catholic Church.
Nice try though.