[metmom]

But it certainly is true that theres an us/them situation set up, wherein only the Catholics are identified, the rest, no matter how different from each other, are united against Catholics. That is the only reason anyone should ever be interested.

Fine. You're Catholic. I'm Evangelical. It's the same broad level of disclosure.

You want specific denominations? Then start posting specific rites and parishes. That would provide the same risk of your compromising your screen name that your demands would put on others.

If you're not willing to go beyond *Catholic*, which leaves us some alleged 1.2 billion people to choose from, then we're not willing to go beyond *Protestant* or *Evangelical* and it puts Catholics in no position to criticize others for not being more specific.

[Judith Anne]

Fine. You're Catholic. I'm Evangelical. It's the same broad level of disclosure.

I don't recall asking you anything about your denominational affiliation on this thread. 1000silverlings brought it up in 12571. I don't recall expressing any curiosity about your denomination affiliation on this thread.

Do not make this about me.