Because they did it openly.
Okay, that’s ringing a bell. I vaguely recall (I’ve been more than usually thick headed for about 3 weeks owing to another Physician prescribed poison) that there was a htought that a solas/orthodox caucus was going to be started.
So there was conversation about the potentially bogus nature of the Caucus and a plan discussed to bring it down?
IF so, it’s a shame that the attempt was muddied up with an OP which made it easy to pull down the Caucus status.
If I wanted to make the experiment, I’d find an Orthodox person to work with and look for something that was more positive in its language. This case is too muddy to establish a new point IMHO.