For that statement to be wrong you must either believe in more than one God or believe that Muslims perfectly describe and worship Him. Which is it?
You’re using logical reasoning there. It won’t work with these folks. They’re immune to it. They’re driven by an irrational animus against all things Catholic.
I would be happy to see a reasonable non-Catholic discuss these issues of theology and Scripture in a measured and respectful way on this thread, but I’m not holding out much hope. Unfortunately, under the “open thread” rules in effect, anyone can come here anonymously and hurl all sorts of vile ephithets at Catholics, as long as they don’t “get personal” with an individual poster.
That’s the way it is, I suppose. I wouldn’t be surprised to come back here in ten years and find the same individuals here all day long posting the same bigoted remarks, and the gentleman with the colors and the giant letters cheering them on.
Oh, well...It’s in God’s hands.