Did it seem "odd" that God would save Noah and not the rest of humanity? Or lot and not the rest of Sodom or that He choose israel out of all the nations to bless ?
The Bible tells us that God has a remnant not that he has a whole "bolt" :)
There is much that remain a part of the secret counsel of God ...we do not need to know the answer, we just need to trust God knows what is right
The Flood and the destruction of Sodom, etc. PRECEEDED Christ’s Sacrifice.
What you are describing is the notion that the rules can somehow change AFTER His Sacrifice.