[Mad Dawg]

This is one reason it is so hard to discuss things.

The first proposition again is or seems to be "a sinless human is God or a god and not human."

There may be other good arguments about Mary but it's not a discussion if one point is raised and and then abandoned for another when the first point is questioned. If ALL the arguments you have cannot bear scrutiny, then is any of them any good? And if none of them is any good, how can they be good in the aggregate?

If you are going to say that if Mary is sinless then she is God or a god (and I could use help on knowing which you are maintaining) that is not self-evident. There must be some thought behind it. I disagree with the proposition, so I'd like to know the thought behind it.

[RnMomof7]

God is sinless, Jesus was sinless.. One of the attributes of God is impeccability are you assigning an attribute of God to Mary..in doing so do you not make her a god?

Is impeccability ..an attribute of God that He transfer to men? If God can do that why bother with the cross? He could have simply made all men after the fall sinless