[Petronski]

You'll forgive me if I didn't thumb through every single post...

Of course.

But if you're not going to read every single post, you ought not make sweeping claims like "There has never been a cogent argument put forward against Jedediah."

[Quix]

.

[roamer_1]

But if you're not going to read every single post, you ought not make sweeping claims like "There has never been a cogent argument put forward against Jedediah."

Alright. How about this:

I have read the lion's share of these threads and I have yet to find a cogent argument put forward against Jedediah.