[kosta50]

I already demonstrated how you can not substantiate your claim of "contradiction" in violation Trent, nor can you demonstrate Feenyism without ignoring my qualifier in taking up YOUR challenge.

Before you go on any further, it is time perhaps for you to demonstrate just whose teaching do you espouse here other than your own? Which Pope of Council or Magisterial pronouncmeent expresses your views on this subject? I think it is disingenuous for you to ask for evidence when you have none to offer to back up the interpretations you are spouting.

[papertyger]

I think it is disingenuous for you to ask for evidence when you have none to offer to back up the interpretations you are spouting.

I don't...particularly when the alternative put forth so far is a preposterous notion that apostasy is some how dependent on geography!