No. You weren't (and aren't) rationally, logically, internally consistent. I'm sure the man was surprised that people who are so scientific on Genesis suddenly morph into "simple believers" when it comes to the sixth chapter of John. I don't understand it, either.
Right, I’m sure he was shocked there was any outrage at all, considering what Catholics believe or not about Genesis. And I’m sure he would have never have done it at all if only Catholics believed a certain way about the old Testament.
You said Catholics deserved having this guy do this. Even if you disagree with Catholics, you really think we deserved him doing that? That is just sick.
Freegards