Please note that stockpirate posted that in response to post 15 where it was stated "Communion" at a Protestant church is meaningless. "
Esssentially stockpirate was saying that such a sentiment - unfortunately so obviously on display here, that a Catholic communion is the only meaningful communion - is simply wrong. And we are all saved, regardless of what we believe in terms of doctrine if we have a personal relationship with Christ.
It seemed quite obvious to me...
“And we are all saved, regardless of what we believe in terms of doctrine if we have a personal relationship with Christ.”
Every Catholic in a State of Grace does have a personal, physical relationship with Our Lord. Q. E. D.
You admit then that every Catholic in a State of Grace is saved, no?