[conservativegramma]

Please respect the right of Catholics to define their faith.

Why? You don't respect the position of Protestants over sola scriptura. You attack that and claim its not biblical and tell us what to believe, even though it is biblically supported. This entire thread was posted as an attack. You honestly didn't expect those who believe this to sit back and say nothing did you???? Something like this thread gets posted, expect to get some heat in return.

[Petronski]

Here is a parallel situation. If I claimed that your belief of sola scriptura meant you believed Scripture is actually a part of a new Quartine Godhead, I would be misrepresenting your belief--and grotesquely so.

Just like when you claim we believe Mary is a goddess--when we do not--grotesquely misrepresents our beliefs.

[Quix]

Now, now.

You should know . . .

AN OUTRAGEOUS DOUBLE STANDARD

IS part of the RC magicsterical's RUBBERIZED DOGMA mandatory not only on the part of the faithful but mandatory on the part of everyone everywhere--kind of like the Jihadi's--either be Muslim or pay tribute, or have your head cut off. No other options.

Only in this case--it's the routine double standard.

From the double standard treatment they demand and get from an unknown number of alternate mods . . . to the double standard of their rubber logic . . . to the double standard of how they demand, DEMAND to be treated vs how they insist on treating Prottys . . . It's all standard RC magicsterical duplicity. And it reaches back, pretty much, to the beginning of the RC edifice 1600 years ago.