[MHGinTN]

That is an mischaracterization! And in making it over somethng I asked of the poster you drag me into your mischaracterization. He did not say he does not consider you Christians. To the contrary, are we not told by God to edify one another, to admonish one another. Would a fellow Christian be edified by you mischarterizing his post, trying to paint it in the extreme? You verify the clarity of his comment because you have now exhibited ‘limited judgment’ just like we admit to falling into on occasion.

[Religion Moderator]

Discuss the issues all you want, but do not make it personal.

[Dr. Eckleburg]

Look, you brought me and a few other posters into your question to Mark. I didn't ask him that question, and I didn't ask you to ask him for me.

Next time, ask him for yourself and leave me out of your suppositions.

Regardless, his statement stands on its own.

He did not say he does not consider you Christians...you mischaracterizing his post

You asked him if he thought I and a few others were Christians, to which he replied...

"There are times when in my limited judgement that I believe that they depart from the belief."

Depart from what belief? A belief in Christ? The Christian belief? Or was he speaking about a belief in leprechauns or maybe the flat tax?

As much as I think the RCC is riddled with mysticism, idolatry and tyranny, I would never presume to say a Roman Catholic was not a Christian. I'm appalled at Mark's response, and frankly, I'm amazed at yours.

But A-G has the right attitude. C'est la vie.