Luther was still Catholic compared to Finney.....
I agree with you; I'm more in sympathy with Luther than Finney. It's also odd that I got a high Calvin and a low Luther; you'd think those two would track more closely.
I think perhaps you have to hit "agree" on the "Papacy is a tool of the devil" question to get a high Luther score.
Luther (and probably Calvin) were “more Catholic” than most of the feel-good, Kumbaya-singing, post-Vatican II CINOs who are polluting the Church today. When you look at what they do and how they act, it is obvious (though most of them would be horrified by the suggestion) that they have less respect for papal authority than any of the original Protestant Reformation leaders.