I like it.
The degeneration of this thread (which began as a "Catholic Caucus" vanity proposal by MarkOMalley) is a perfect example of why my idea (expressed above) will never happen on FR.
Thanks, Carolina, for your idea about the Pontificator blog. Perhaps it will be my next destination? It is undoubtedly a blog with moderated comments that bounces comments by those who would lead discussion into the woods so as to lose the gems posted and real inquiry into a meaningful direction.
Such a sad state of affairs.