I am entitled to disagree with Carson.
Jesus didn't say both. It wasn't a plural. The "this Rock" either applies to Peter or Peter's confession. Not both.
I do not take my orders from Man. I take them from Scripture - as Scripture says I should.
I knew you would.
Anyone who disagrees with your personal opinions is wrong. And, that includes Scripture, Jesus, Church Fathers, Saints, Ecumenical Councils, Catechisms, Systematic Theologians like Augustine and Aquinas, and men like St John of the Cross etc etc.
You are the Christian Cheese, so to speak :)