This thread was posted by a Catholic and Catholic lists were pinged. Then, as so often happens, a group of Protestants arrived to challenge Catholic beliefs.
Now I'm sure you know that the original poster didn't post this thread as a Catholic caucus thread ... and that it, therefore, is an open discussion.
And Catholics began the thread by negatively critiquing what they saw as a particularly Protestant portrayal of Mary in the Nativity Story.
Can you be more specific? I reread the first twenty or so posts and didn't see any of this until Protestants came along.