[Uncle Chip]

Since you have already shown yourself to be willing to make things up, I'm not going to accept your claim that Sullivan's book has the nihil obstat, without some verification.

Why should it even matter if what he said is true and the result of honest scholarship? Oh no --- don't tell me --- have they dug up his bones too and burned them?

[adiaireton8]

Why should it even matter if what he said is true and the result of honest scholarship?

Because you are trying to create the appearance of a contradiction within orthodox Catholicism. If Sullivan's book lacks the nihil obstat (and I suspect that it does), then your case for a contradiction within orthodox Catholicism is obviously deficient.

-A8