[FJ290]

Well of course!! I remember reading right there in my Bible the requirements for music to be either of the tradition of Gregorian chants or sacred polyphony.

I don't remember reading right there in the Bible "Rapping for Jesus" or "Rocking and Rolling for Jesus."

[billbears]

What does shout with a joyful noise unto the Lord mean to you? Humming along to a group of monks in monotone? As I said I'm not up for all new worship but this takes it back a little too far.

FWIW, I'm not Catholic and besides having to learn a cornucopia of prayers, sayings, and catchphrases, this is one reason. I have enough time remembering the Apostle's Creed

As I said, whatever floats your boat