[Theoden]

How can they claim to be Catholic, when they cannot follow the teachings of the Church on obedience, communion with Rome, the Papal Primacy, etc...

The SSPX is vicious in it's attacks on the post Vatican II Papacy, from Pope John XXIII right up to Pope Benedict XVI, especially on those Popes who extended to the SSPX for reconciliation. They do not believe these Popes are legitimate, just like Protestants! I guess they do not under stand that the Holy Spirit guides the Church, and Vatican II was meant to come about. "The gates of hell shall not prevail against it".

The day will come when the SSPX leadership stands before Saint Peter, and I can imagine him asking of them, "So, why did YOU break from the Catholic Church?". All the while St. Peter is dangling the keys before them.

[technochick99]

How can they claim to be Catholic, when they cannot follow the teachings of the Church on obedience, communion with Rome

I suppose you could say that about a lot of regular parishes in our country. They're just a little more quiet about it...

[Slugworth]

The SSPX is vicious in it's attacks on the post Vatican II Papacy, from Pope John XXIII right up to Pope Benedict XVI, especially on those Popes who extended to the SSPX for reconciliation. They do not believe these Popes are legitimate, just like Protestants!

Can you back this up, or are you just repeating what you've heard?