Posted on 07/16/2005 7:36:30 AM PDT by sionnsar
From the Wall Street Journal, the Orthodox writer Frederica Mathewes-Green gives her perspective on the idea of unity between Roman Catholics and the Eastern Orthodox, in All for One. She makes a number of good points, I think--including this:
From a Roman Catholic perspective, unity is created by the institution of the church. Within that unity there can be diversity; not everyone agrees with official teaching, some very loudly. What holds things together is membership. This kind of unity makes immediate sense to Americans: Whatever their disagreements, everyone salutes the flag, and all Catholics salute, if not technically obey, Rome's magisterium.From my perspective as an outsider to both traditions, I think she is correct: Rome's unity is largely based on the institution of the Papacy (although at the top there is indeed the basis for uniformity of belief--see the Catechism of the Catholic Church), and Orthodoxy's unity seems to be more based on a commonality of belief. Will this ever be resolved? It seems that a commonality of belief between the two communions will have to come first.
When Roman Catholics look at Orthodoxy, they don't see a centralized, global institution. Instead, the church appears to be a jumble of national and ethnic bodies (a situation even more confused in the U.S. as a result of immigration). To Catholics, the Orthodox Church looks like chaos.
But from an Orthodox perspective, unity is created by believing the same things. It's like the unity among vegetarians or Red Sox fans. You don't need a big bureaucracy to keep them faithful. Across wildly diverse cultures, Orthodox Christians show remarkable unity in their faith. (Of course there are plenty of power struggles and plain old sin, but the essential faith isn't challenged.) What's the source of this common faith? The consensus of the early church, which the Orthodox stubbornly keep following. That consensus was forged with many a bang and dent, but for the past millennium major questions of faith and morals have been pretty much at rest in the Eastern hemisphere.
ping
Interesting, albeit a tad simplistic. Pinging the Catholics and Orthodox for their input.
Oops. Re-posted...
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.