[Unam Sanctam]

But nothing you have said contradicts the basic soundness of the notion that those convicted under Church law of abusing the young should receive zero tolerance. I just don't see what is "politically correct" or wrong about that notion -- it seems common sense to me.

[cebadams]

>> ... those convicted under Church law of abusing the young should receive zero tolerance.

Criminal activity (of any kind) should be handled by the local criminal justice system first -- give unto Caesar and all that. The whole Church tribunal thing is a diversion and will tend to keep complaints behind closed doors. Only those complaints that make it into the public forum will be dealt the zero-tolerance policy.

If there isn't a conviction from the local criminal justice system then and only then should the local Church legal system step in to determine whether there is cause for further action.