[Wrigley]

Does the Good Shephard lose any of his sheep?

[IMRight]

Does the Good Shephard lose any of his sheep?

Not the real question here.

The OSAS issue begs "can any of the sheep choose to leave?" not whether He loses them.

The TULIP issue begs "We're they all sheep to begin with? Or we're they 'adopted' into the fold later?"

[al_c]

Does the Good Shephard lose any of his sheep?

He certainly chases after them. But it's still our choice to follow or not.