[BabsC]

He's right the Liberty was totally out of position. Most of the mistakes were on the American side as far as putting that ship where it should not have been. We had the communications breakdown while Israel is fighting for it's life and put our ship in harms way.

How are you reconciling the killing of Canadians in Afghanastan by our troops? Or is it just that the Jews were on the delivery end of this mistake and that makes it a conspiracy?

[harrowup]

...makes it a conspiracy?

There was no conspiracy. Israeli commanders made a decision to attack everything that was of non-Israeli military value. They knew damn well Liberty was there.

Who was to blame and who is lying is up to God.

[KantianBurke]

His religion is irrelevent. His blaming the victims act is not however. Mistake or not, he and his budies launched an attack on US forces that ended with many deaths. He could at least sound remorseful rather than strident.

[AzSteven]

Or is it just that the Jews were on the delivery end of this mistake and that makes it a conspiracy?

And how is the logic of this statement any different than saying 'Criticism of an African-American is automatically racist'? Expressing doubt about the official Liberty story is not anti-Semitism.