[southernnorthcarolina]

I'm calling this debate for Arnold for beating expectations, and for Tom for substance. Well done for both guys.

I essentially agree.

God-awful format, God-awful moderator, all made worse by Arianna, the fingernails on my blackboard of life. Notwithstanding that, I'd score it on content and presentation thusly:

Arnold: content 7, presentation 9, total 16

Tom: content 8, presentation 7, total 15

Cruse: content 3, presentation 5, total 8

Green Guy: content 2, presentation 4, total 6

Arianna: content 0, presentation 1, total 1

[alancarp]

I definitely rate Tom Mc. highest: Arnold was funny, but that's not appropriate here -- got caught up too much with AH, who should have been voted off within the first two minutes.

Boost was 3rd. Peter Green ranted into a fourth.

[JENINMO]

Excellent scoring, I would only add a category for entertainment factor ;0

[orbitboy]

Arnold: content 6, presentation 9, total 15

Tom: content 8, presentation 5, total 13

Cruse: content 2, presentation 2, total 4

Green Guy: content 0, presentation 1, total 1

Arianna: content 0, presentation -1, total -1

[Mad_Tom_Rackham]

My input follows:

Green Guy: content 2, presentation 4, psychosis modifier -15, total -90 Arianna: content 0, presentation 1, annoyance factor -20, Perot clone -5, total -25