[mhking]

Good article, John; I'll admit that I see your point, but I'm still not there yet. This looks completely schizophrenic entirely. Not only that, it looks like it'll be back before the justices in a few years in another form...

[Congressman Billybob]

Chief Justice Rehnquist, in his dissent in the Grutter case predicts what you suggest. He says he expects this half-way case to generate a tide of litigation as lawyers seek to push around the fuzzy boundaries of this decision. I think you, and he, are right on the mark to suggest that as the outcome.

Billybob

[lepton]

Not only that, it looks like it'll be back before the justices in a few years in another form...

Only if they let it.

How long since they've reviewed the mess in the courts over the 2nd Amendment? 1939.