Know any other Div. 1 conferences where the same player won three years in a row? Didn't think so.
Most Div 1 conferences are more competitive than that. ;>) I'd have to look, but it may well have happened in the SWC in the 70's (Crenshaw-UT), the PAC10 in the 80's (Mickleson-AZ), or perhaps whatever conference UofH played in before SWC. All those conferences / schools are legendary golf venues that have graduated numerous Tour players over the years.
Seriously, tho, you were trying to make a point that there might be men more 'deserving' of an exemption than AS. As 'evidence', you asserted that:
..there is a kid in Westchester right now who has won the Big East Conference individual championship three years in a row ..
According to the Big East Conference site, there have been no recent 3-peaters, presidio. The only golf 3-peater that the site shows is a guy from 20 years ago - is that the kid to which you refer? A (presumably) 42 yo kid who might better spend his life accepting the fact that he ain't gonna be playing in the bigs?
In short, you appear to be decidedly truth-challenged, presidio. Methinks (as do many others here) that you're just making it up as you go.