Now in retirement, bad back , bad knees from thin air PLF's ect ect (sudden stops not the mileage ), and a sedate job I use the adkins diet to "help" keep the weight off. A bit of sleep apnea that wasn't discovered "officially" till I'd gained a hundred pounds almost killed me and now with a CPAP and Atkins I'm almost back to fighting weight.
Everyone is different. I have known 130 pound weaklings that are junk food junkies and never gain an ounce. Yet others that will watch that individual eat the carbs and gain weight just looking on per se :o) Thus I say regulate your diet for the lifestyle you live. If Atkin does it for ya then by all means do so. It works for me at this stage in my life.
Stay Safe !
Thanks for your thoughts--you are correct, sir!