Chirac on the other hand...
Regards, Ivan
Posted on 03/11/2003 3:48:11 PM PST by MadIvan
ADOLF HITLER may have been dying of syphilis when he committed suicide in his Berlin bunker, according to a new book that could explain the Führer’s mental decline in the final months of the Second World War.
New analysis of the records kept by Hitler’s doctors has revealed that he suffered from many of the most characteristic symptoms of tertiary syphilis, and that he was treated regularly with drugs that were commonly prescribed for the sexually transmitted disease.
The controversial diagnosis, which would cast fresh light on the dictator’s behaviour, from his sexual frigidity to his paranoiac rages, is advanced in Pox: Genius, Madness and the Mysteries of Syphilis, by Deborah Hayden, an American historian. While it may never be possible to prove that Hitler was syphilitic, the balance of evidence suggests the disease as the most likely explanation for the wide range of health problems that afflicted him, particularly in his last years.
“If Hitler’s life is looked at through the selective lens of a possible diagnosis of syphilis, one clue leads to another and then another until, when they are all assembled and looked at in order, a pattern of infection and progressive disease emerged,” said Ms Hayden, a former lecturer on the history of the disease at the University of California at San Francisco. “Syphilis must then be considered in our understanding of Hitler’s career, his motivations, the events of World War Two, and even the Holocaust.”
The theory that Hitler had syphilis has been advanced before, most notably by the Nazi-hunter Simon Wiesenthal, but has generally been rejected for lack of proof. Ms Hayden has amassed an unprecedented wealth of circumstantial evidence, although she accepts that the diagnosis will never be irrefutable.
“This is not definitive proof, but I think there is a preponderance of circumstantial evidence,” she said. “It certainly might have affected his mind. It could have supercharged what was going on, and if he knew or thought he had it, and didn’t have long to live, it may have accelerated the war effort.”
Aside from the well-known mania of his last years, which would be consistent with the mental effects of the parasite, the Führer had an abnormal heartbeat that points towards syphilitic aortitis. Notes kept by Theo Morell, Hitler’s personal physician, show that he had an accentuated or “tympanic” second sound to the heartbeat, which is often caused by syphilitic damage to the aorta.
Dr Morell’s records of drug treatment show that from 1941 Hitler received regular injections of iodide salts, a standard 1940s therapy for cardiac syphilis. He had lesions on his shins so painful that they sometimes prevented him from wearing boots, and suffered intermittently from encephalitis, dizziness, flatulence, neck pustules, chest pain, gastric pain and restrictive palsies — all are associated with the disease.
A knowledge that he carried the disease would explain his lack of sexual interest towards his long-term consort and eventual bride, Eva Braun, and his devotion of 13 pages of Mein Kampf to syphilis. “The question of combating syphilis should have been made to appear as the task of the nation,” he wrote.
Hitler’s very appointment of Dr Morell in 1936, Ms Hayden suggests, is significant. The doctor, a dermatologist, was one of Germany’s leading experts on the disease.
Several contemporary rumours, including one spread by Putzi Hanfstaengl, a friend of Hitler from the 1920s, held that he had contracted syphilis from a prostitute in Vienna in 1908 or 1910. Some accounts suggested that the prostitute was Jewish. Ms Hayden said that these were probably hearsay, but that Hitler did write in Mein Kampf that the Jews were responsible for spreading the disease. His experience of syphilis may thus have influenced his anti-Semitism.
More plausible are reports that Hitler was given the diagnosis at a German field hospital in 1918, when he was recovering from a gas attack, she said. Heinrich Himmler, the SS chief, may have held and destroyed copies of his medical records, according to the book. Hitler is widely thought to have taken the Wassermann test for the disease, with a negative result, but this should not rule out the diagnosis, Ms Hayden said. The sample was labelled only “Patient A”, and thus may not have come from Hitler.
Robert Berger, a cardiac surgeon at Harvard Medical School in Boston, said Hitler’s symptoms could indicate a diagnosis of syphilis. “The total picture is consistent with syphilis, though it is not definitive. Each of the symptoms and treatments fits.”
Rudolph Binion, Professor of History at Brandeis University in Massachusetts and author of Hitler Among the Germans, said that the diagnosis would fit with almost every aspect of Hitler’s known medical symptoms and behaviour. “While it’s impossible to diagnose with 100 per cent surety, she has an extremely presumptive case. It falls in very much with a case of textbook syphilis,” he said.
However Sir Ian Kershaw, Professor of History at Sheffield University and one of Hitler’s most authoritative biographers, was not convinced. Rumours of Hitler’s condition were based on “dodgy hearsay”, he said, adding: “I remain heartily sceptical.”
Great and the good who were hit by French pox
SYPHILIS is thought to have originated in the Americas and to have begun its devastating spread around the world after Christopher Columbus’s voyage in 1492.
The first major epidemic of the disease broke out in Europe in 1494, spread at least in part by French troops retreating from the siege of Naples, giving rise to its first nicknames: “the disease of Naples” and “the French pox”.
The French philosopher Voltaire had his own views on its national origins. “The first fruit the Spaniards brought from the New World was syphilis,” he wrote.
In fact, syphilis may have been present in Europe before Columbus, although it became commonplace only with the arrival of new strains from the New World. Female bones dug up in 2001 in a churchyard in Rivenhall, near Witham, Essex, which have been dated to between 1290 and 1445, show characteristic syphilitic damage.
Whatever its provenance, the disease began to sweep through the European population in the 16th century, and there is good evidence that it afflicted Charles VIII and Francis I of France and Ivan the Terrible of Russia. Mary Tudor of England may have had the congenital version of the disease, inherited from her father, Henry VIII.
At its peak in the 19th century, syphilis may have affected as many as 15 per cent of the adult population of Europe and North America, according to Deborah Hayden’s book. The disease, which is caused by the parasite Treponema pallidum, has largely died out since the development of penicillin in the 1940s.
Many sufferers were celebrated artists, authors, politicians and philosophers. Figures who are known to have had the disease include the French novelists Gustave Flaubert and Guy de Maupassant, the French poet Charles Baudelaire and the German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche.
Ms Hayden suggests several more controversial diagnoses. Vincent van Gogh may have begun to paint images involving death after contracting the disease, she suggests, and Ludwig van Beethoven, Abraham Lincoln, James Joyce and Oscar Wilde may also have suffered.
Chirac on the other hand...
Regards, Ivan
I agree with you. Most people want a short definitive explanation for Hitler. Let's blame an unknown, syphillitic Jewish prostitue in Vienna for the Holocaust!
But the truth is far more prosaic and horrible. He was evil, he created a regime that rewarded monstrous behavior, those that wanted to get ahead eagerly participated, the "great masses" went along because, if they didn't have to get their hands dirty, they basically agreed with Hitler.
That was the first thing that came to mind. It would be just desserts for ol' bubba.
The symptoms are so varied and variable that it's dicey to make a diagnosis without seeing the little spirochetes on the slide . . .
There's a thriving cottage industry in speculating Who in History may have had The French Disease. I remember reading a highly amusing book speculating that Henry VIII had it and transmitted it to Edward, Mary AND Elizabeth . . . it essentially was a bunch of doctors with an interest in history shooting the breeze over a couple of beers.
Makes for an interesting evening but I wouldn't bet a steak dinner on it . . .
This may not be hard and fast, but as a general rule patients got one or the other manifestation of tertiary syphilis but not both . If you got aortitis you didn't get neurosyphilis and vice versa.
As I indicated there may be some exceptions to this rule, but as a general rule, aortic anomalies don't lend credence to a diagnosis of neurosyphilis.
Regards, Ivan
Regards, Ivan
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.