Jurors deciding Harris' punishment (Clara Harris murder trial)

Houston Chronicle ^ | February 14, 2003 | By ALLAN TURNER

[MeekOneGOP]

HoustonChronicle.com -- http://www.HoustonChronicle.com | Section: Local & State

Feb. 14, 2003, 12:32PM

Jurors deciding Harris' punishment

By ALLAN TURNER
Copyright 2003 Houston Chronicle

RESOURCES

Clara Harris listens to the verdict with her lawyers.

• The story of Clara Harris

---

THE TRIAL
Video: The jury delivers its verdict
• Key testimony from the trial
• The indictment:
The state of Texas vs. Clara Harris
• What we know about them

The testimony:
• Day 1: Hotel employees tell what they saw
• Day 2: Grainy videotape reveals little
• Day 3: What the private eye learned
• Day 4: Defendant's sobs halt trial twice
• Day 5: Stepdaughter says Clara Harris 'went straight for him'
• Day 6: Defense expert says Mercedes only hit him once
• Day 7: Physical evidence vs. eyewitnesses
• Day 8: David Harris' employees say affair disrupted workplace
• Day 9: Mistress testifies of 'open marriage'
• Day 10: Clara Harris takes the stand
• Day 11: She doesn't remember hitting her husband
• Day 12: David Harris' mom says marriage "made in heaven"
• Day 13: Witnesses say car hit victim three times
• Closing arguments: Jurors get option of a conviction less than murder

---

Video:
Private investigator catches incident on tape

---

From the Chronicle's archives:
• The story of Clara and David Harris: They epitomized success and happiness, but underneath the facade... - Jan. 19
• The wife: Mother of twins kept to herself - Aug. 4
• The mistress: Mistress not a stranger to the spotlight - Aug. 4
• The married couple: Victim wanted to end marriage - July 27

---

(Video courtesy of KHOU, Ch. 11. Video requires Real Player)

After deciding Thursday that dentist Clara Harris is guilty of murder in the July 24 automobile attack on her adulterous husband, jurors today began deliberating on how she should be punished.

If their deliberations conclude today, Harris will know her fate on the 11th anniversary of her marriage to the man she killed.

Final arguments in the penalty phase began with prosecutor Mia Magness calling for jail time for Clara Harris, though she did not specify an amount.

"Probation -- scratch that," Magness said. However, she also told them to "scratch" a life-in-prison penalty.

Defense attorney George Parnham asked the jury to spare his client from any jail time.

Parnham often spoke quietly and haltingly. He appealed for probation, telling the jury that the Harrises' twin sons should not be "ripped away" from the arms of their surviving parent.

Parnham warned that his opponent, prosecutor Mia Magness, would tell the jury in her rebuttal that their decision would "send a message."

"But it won't stop the Gail Thompson Bridges of the world from doing what they do," Parnham said, referring to the David Harris' mistress.

During Parnham's arguments, Clara Harris wept, occasionally holding her head in her hands. He painted a picture of his client as a model citizen prior to the killing.

"Clara Harris is respected by her neighbors, loved by her neighors, loved by the colleagues she employed, loved by the family that was closest to David," he said. "She worked hard. She was a good mother, a good wife. She has requested and she will be able to abide by terms of probation."

Parnham completed his arguments at about 10 a.m., and prosecutor Magness started her rebuttal, attacking the defense's strategy of painting the defendant as a good person.

"You are not asked to punish her as a person, you are being asked to punish her conduct," Magness said. "Her conduct of July 24 is what you should be basing your decision on."

Magness called Clara Harris "selfish" for the actions that led up to and caused her husband's death, and for involving David Harris' daughter, Lindsey Harris.

"To even involve a teenage daughter in what should have remained something resolved by adults -- to involve her to the point that that child has to witness the death of her father is unconscionable," she said.

Lindsey Harris was the prosecution's sole witness during the punishment phase.

The prosecutor also countered Parnham's argument that the boys should not be deprived of their mother.

"She is using her children as a shield," Magness said.

Magness said that, as the defense tried to paint Clara Harris as a woman who suffered humiliation, David Harris' humiliation was forgotten.

"How about drowning in your own blood while your teenage daughter watches?" she asked. "You talk about humiliation? What about his?

"Every single one of us has the right, no matter who you are, or what choices you make in life, to die with dignity. It is what you hope for. And she took that away from him," Magness said.

She completed her arguments at about 10:25 a.m. As state District Judge Carolyn Davies announced a brief recess before jury deliberations would start, defense attorney Emily Munoz stood.

Munoz said she wanted it noted in the record -- though without an objection -- that the court reporter was crying and that Magness was near tears during her rebuttal. She called the behavior "prejudicial as the public displays of emotion that Clara has displayed during the trial."

Thursday, at least two members of the panel of nine women and three men wept as their verdict was read shortly after 9 a.m.

The conviction could send Harris to prison for five to 99 years or life. If sentenced to 10 years or less, she would be eligible for probation.

If jurors determine that Harris killed her husband in "sudden passion," she could be eligible for a prison sentence as short as two years.

The jury also found that Harris had used her S-body Mercedes-Benz sedan as a deadly weapon -- a finding that would keep her in prison during her appeals and require her to serve half of her assessed sentence before she could become eligible for parole.

The jurors, who received the case about noon Wednesday, deliberated for slightly more than eight hours before announcing the decision. They are set to begin considering Harris' punishment today.

Harris, 45, was accused of running over her husband, orthodontist David Harris, in a fit of jealous rage after she found him with his mistress at a Clear Lake-area hotel.

The victim, 44, suffered massive injuries in the attack, including 16 broken ribs and a broken back, jaw, collarbone and pelvis. His lungs were punctured and a blood vessel to his heart torn.

The murder vehicle, a 2000 model valued at $55,125, was impounded by police and will become part of David Harris' estate.

Clara Harris, who frequently cried openly during the trial, stood dry-eyed as the verdict was delivered. Defense attorneys Parnham and Munoz gently gripped her arms.

A short time later, however, she burst into tears as prosecutor Magness questioned the state's only witness in the punishment phase, the defendant's 17-year-old stepdaughter, Lindsey Harris.

Asked about the quality of her life since her father's murder, the teen was testifying about two incidents in which she slashed her wrists when state District Judge Carol G. Davies called for a short break.

As jurors filed from the courtroom, Clara Harris stood at the defense table and sobbed, "I'm sorry, Lindsey. I'm sorry, baby."

"Be quiet!" Davies commanded.

"I'm sorry. I'm sorry," Harris continued.

"Be quiet!" Davies said again before sternly warning Harris for the fourth time during the trial that she would be removed if she continued to disrupt proceedings.

Although Harris controlled her emotions and remained in the courtroom, two members of the audience later left when Davies admonished spectators to stop reacting emotionally to the proceedings or leave.

Lindsey Harris -- who lives with her mother and stepfather in Ohio -- told jurors she had a "great" relationship with her father.

"I talked to him on the phone every other day," she said. "We were the same person. We finished each other's sentences."

The teen testified that they shared interests, including music, athletics and dentistry.

"I planned to come to college down here and spend the rest of my life down here," she said. "Everything was planned. It was just perfect. And then it was ruined."

She told jurors of the harrowing minutes when, as a passenger in her stepmother's car, she recognized that her father would die.

"I saw his eyes," she said of the incident in the parking lot of the Nassau Bay Hilton. "I felt so bad that I couldn't help him. He couldn't get away. He was so scared and I couldn't do anything.

"It was terrifying. She was killing him. I would never see him again. I never got to say goodbye. I only got to spend 16 1/2 years with him. I had plans. It just wasn't fair."

Once she returned to the family's Friendswood home, she testified, she found her father's clothing in a garbage can -- placed there by a nanny on the instructions of Clara Harris.

The daughter said she brought the clothes upstairs and put them on her bed, then got her father's possessions from his bathroom and closet and brought them to her room.

"I felt like he was there with me," she said.

Lindsey Harris testified that she fantasized that the reason she could not talk with her father was that he was away on business. Once an A student, she said, she began making Ds. She dropped out of a cheerleading program, lost her friends and no longer cared about becoming an orthodontist.

The teenager said she slipped into depression, underwent counseling and was placed on mood-altering medication.

"It made things worse," she said. "I was just numb."

She told jurors she has become estranged from her grandparents, Mildred and Gerald Harris, who have continued to support their daughter-in-law. She suggested that their support of the killer stemmed in part from financial reasons linked to their son's estate.

Gerald Harris, the defense's first witness in the punishment phase, denied his granddaughter's claim.

"No, sir," said the former high school principal. "That hasn't anything to do with it. I don't expect to get anything out of it.

"Our motivation stems from the word `forgiveness,' " Harris said. "This tragedy has been a strong blow to our family. God has forgiven our sins. We can forgive a member of our family when she has erred."

He told jurors that he and his wife, Mildred, are seeking to gain guardianship of Clara Harris' 4-year-old twin sons.

Gerald Harris, his wife and son, Gerald Jr., were among witnesses called by Parnham to testify that Clara Harris would be a good candidate for probation. Others included her minister, an across-the-street neighbor and the former Colombian consul-general for Texas and Oklahoma.

Defense attorneys elicited testimony that Harris could support her children, hold a job, live as a law-abiding citizen and comply with community-service requirements -- all conditions for probation. She would not be able to perform dental work as community service, however, because she will lose her license because of the murder conviction.

As testimony continued into the afternoon, she continually wrote on a yellow legal pad or gazed at photographs she had placed in front of her on the defense table. The subject of her writing or the content of the photos could not be determined.

Both the prosecution and defense rested their cases late Thursday afternoon, with Parnham asking that all evidence introduced in the trial's guilt-innocence phase be made available to jurors to support a "sudden passion" defense.

David Harris was killed after his wife and daughter found him with his mistress, Gail Bridges, in the lobby of the Nassau Bay Hilton. Testimony showed that Clara Harris was involved in a physical altercation with Bridges before the group was escorted to the parking lot.

Final arguments are expected today, which would have been the 11th wedding anniversary for Harris and her husband.

Harris, who was required to remove her wedding ring and other jewelry, was allowed to say goodbye to her family before being taken to the Harris County Jail, where she will be lodged pending the completion of sentencing.

Chronicle reporters Lisa Teachey, Ruth Rendon and Leigh Hopper contributed to this story.

[MeekOneGOP]

TODAY'S TOP STORIES

Jurors deciding Harris' fate
After deciding Thursday that dentist Clara Harris is guilty of murder in the July 24 automobile attack on her adulterous husband, jurors today began deliberating on how she should be punished. With video, photo gallery.

• Harris legal defense strategy wins praise
• Sounding Board for Readers: Reaction to the verdict

---

AP 2-7-2003
Defendant Clara Harris reacts as she
testifies about her husband's affair.

[MeekOneGOP]

Still in deliberations, it appears. Nothing on FOX News, the Dallas Morning News or the Houston Chronicle about a decision yet...

Please let me know if you want ON or OFF my Clara Harris murder trial ping list!. . .don't be shy.

[FreeTally]

This seems pretty quick. Usually, the sentencing hearing is held a couple of weeks or so after the trial phase.

[MeekOneGOP]

I don't understand this part, in bold red:

The prosecutor also countered Parnham's argument that the boys should not be deprived of their mother.

"She is using her children as a shield," Magness said.

Magness said that, as the defense tried to paint Clara Harris as a woman who suffered humiliation, David Harris' humiliation was forgotten.

"How about drowning in your own blood while your teenage daughter watches?" she asked. "You talk about humiliation? What about his?

"Every single one of us has the right, no matter who you are, or what choices you make in life, to die with dignity. It is what you hope for. And she took that away from him," Magness said.

She completed her arguments at about 10:25 a.m. As state District Judge Carolyn Davies announced a brief recess before jury deliberations would start, defense attorney Emily Munoz stood.

Munoz said she wanted it noted in the record -- though without an objection -- that the court reporter was crying and that Magness was near tears during her rebuttal. She called the behavior "prejudicial as the public displays of emotion that Clara has displayed during the trial."

Thursday, at least two members of the panel of nine women and three men wept as their verdict was read shortly after 9 a.m.

I must misunderstand something. Clara cried through half the trial. So the court reporter and the DA shed a little tear and that's a big deal? I know the defense atty. didn't 'object', just made sure it was in the record? What does that do - help their appeal process somehow?...

[Luna]

Defense attorney George Parnham asked the jury to spare his client from any jail time.

"Your Honor, we can't have persons convicted of a felony be imprisoned. We can't have persons convicted of a felony take any responsibility for their crime. It would be unfair and too much to ask of the justice system."

[Station 51]

The Jurors will want to get out before the weekend and will give her 15 years before 5:00 this afternoon.

[Luna]

"Sorry, your Honor. I meant it would be too much to ask of the persons convicted."

[cricket]

Get over it Clara; your tears are about you; no one else.

How absolutely sick; I surely hope Justice continues to prevail. . .

[MeekOneGOP]

You are right, and so do I...

[dennisw]

 

Her scheming shyster striking  out!

Fri Feb 14,12:05 PM ET

Defense attorney George Parnham asks the jury for community supervision rather than jail time for his client Clara Harris Friday, Feb. 14, 2003, in Houston. Harris was found guilty of murder for running down her husband with her Mercedes-Benz after catching him with another woman. (AP Photo/Pat Sullivan, Pool)

 

 

Crazy Clara crying for herself.

 

Fri Feb 14,12:04 PM ET

Clara Harris cries during her attorney's closing remarks in the sentencing phase of her murder trial Friday, Feb. 14, 2003, in Houston. Harris was found guilty of murder for running down her husband with her Mercedes-Benz after catching him with another woman. (AP Photo/Pat Sullivan, Pool)

 

 

Off to the slammer you crazy bat!

Thu Feb 13, 7:20 PM ET

Bailiffs take Clara Harris, center, into custody Thursday, Feb. 13, 2003, in Houston. Harris was found guilty of murder for running down her husband with her car after catching him with another woman. The punishment phase continues on Friday. (AP Photo/Pat Sullivan, POOL)

Thu Feb 13, 7:12 PM ET

Clara Harris removes her jewelry before being taken into custody Thursday, Feb. 13, 2003, in Houston. Harris was found guilty of murder for running down her husband with her Mercedes-Benz after catching him with another woman. Harris, 45, could get a life sentence, or a lesser punishment if the jury concludes she acted with ``sudden passion.'' (AP Photo/Pat Sullivan, Pool)

[MeekOneGOP]

This seems pretty quick. Usually, the sentencing hearing is held a couple of weeks or so after the trial phase.

Texas taking care of business, I guess...

[MeekOneGOP]

Great pics again ! Thanks...

[isthisnickcool]

Get over it Clara; your tears are about you; no one else.

People that have known her for years would not agree. They said she was madly in love with David. Even though he was abusive to her mentally and physically.

But, she killed the man and she must pay. David might have been a jerk but he did not "need killin". As we say in Texas.

The people that know them say that there is no way Clara set out to kill David. But she did kill him and for that she must pay.

[Sweet Hour of Prayer]

You know, in Biblical times, the entire community would have stoned hubby and Gail Bridges... Nowadays, people don't want to hear that, as there would be alot of stoning. It still doesn't change the fact that Dr. Harris made all the choices that led to his death. Even at the hotel after the confrontation between his wife and the mistress he could have left with his wife to demand a divorce. Instead, he chose Gail over his wife and his teenage daughter. He pushed his wife too far and she snapped. She's guilty of murder... but he and Gail are guilty also.

[cricket]

"People that have known her for years would not agree. They said she was madly in love with David. Even though he was abusive to her mentally and physically."

. . .well, interesting take; and cannot imagine her life in jail or out of jail for that matter after this. . .

. . .and you are right on the bottom line.

[MeekOneGOP]

David and Gail made some bad choices, I agree...

[bobbyd]

20 yrs

[bobbyd]

oops......

20 years

[saxxa]

20 years

[MeekOneGOP]

Thanks, folks ! Yes, 20 years...

Here's the link to the detail, fyi...

Jury sentences Harris to 20 years in prison, $10,000 fine
(Clara Harris murder trial)