[Toonces T. Cat]

>>They shouldn't collect, they shouldn't pay.
>>They aren't citizens.

Could'a, should'a, would'a...The fact is they did pay. So, now you want to deny them the ability to collect benefits that they legally and rightfully earned?

Listen, my politics are somewhere to the right of the Arch Duke Ferdinand, but that doesn't negate my belief that it's not okay to rip people off...U.S. citizens or not.

-Toonces

[Protagoras]

See prior post #22

[Protagoras]

So, now you want to deny them the ability to collect benefits that they legally and rightfully earned?

Legally? Please refer to the SS law to determine their legal abilities to collect. And whether they are legally required to pay.

If I had my way, neither would happen. Pay em off, get em out.

Then pay me off, and get me out. It's an immoral scam. But it isn't illegal.

[The Irishman]

I agree with Thomas Jefferson, returning any paltry "contributions" they would have made is more than fair. If the law entitles them to anything more than that, it should be changed reference illegals from Mexico or anywhere else.

Regards.