Here's the rewrite I'd been thinking of for a few days:
I'll let this be my set of defining sentiments on FR:
1. Trent Lott meant exactly what we thought he meant at Strom's birthday party, and confirmed it during his interview on BET when he talked of race, immoral leadership in the South and admitted that he was part of that.
2. There is no objective standard by which anyone can state that government imposed segregation and the Jim Crow laws were good.
3. There is no objective standard by which anyone could say that opposing the end of segregation and the Jim Crow laws was good.
4. There is no objective standard by which anyone can say that the systematic exclusion of a race of people from the economy was good.
5. There is no objective standard by which anyone can say that opposition to full voting rights by blacks was good.
6. That century of apartheid that followed the Civil War left a stain on our history - and there are many people alive today who remember what that was like. It isn't remote and long past - so when blacks cringe over the type of remarks made by Lott, or by talk of states rights, don't moan that they're being PC.
7. It isn't PC pandering to feel some sense of shame over the things people in our parents' and grandparents' generation did. My folks were Wallace voters in '68 - something they're not proud of now. I brought my own grandmother up short when she tried to support Trent Lott based on a very little knowledge and a lot of stored up racial vitriol.
I am sorry..
Lose the "puppy dog" stuff, talk about football and spit allot.
(I hate football also, but when in Rome..)
Something had to give, it was the elephant in the living room that can only go unadressed for so long.
That said though, I think allot of conservatives used the occasion of Lott's (admittedly stupid, no argument) comment as an occasion to lynch him for many other failings.
While these peripheral issues, in and of themselves might well constitute valid a reason for his removal, they weren't addressed. Just his comments on the Thurmond matter.
That's cowardly and dishonest in my opinion.
And I hate Trent Lott.