It has come to my attention that the White House wanted O'Neill's resignation letter released on Monday, but he released it on Friday, probably out of anger and disappointment. I think this was a failure to understand how some people react to disappointing news.
I think the failure to get on top of the sugar issue also hurt. Apparently the charges were a lie, but Terrell's reaction was not strong enough, probably shaving off a couple thousand votes from her camp.
In addition, Mary Landrieu was very smart in keeping all DC Rats out of her state. It allowed her to frame the debate as Louisiana against the world, and also allowed her to portray herself as an underdog.
I think the tone of the election changed from November to December. It is possible that the run-off strategy, while looking good statistically, was actually counterproductive.
It is my hope that Frist and Rove look at these results and analyze all the parameters of why this election was lost. Sometimes one can be too clever by half, and this may have been one of those times. I don't think this is Terrell's last election, and I am almost certain she will still have a career.
Now, I hope you understand my point. I don't like to lose, but it does no good if when we lose we immediately go around shouting "We're doomed!"