Senator Loserman was not available for comment
Citigroup Inc. (NYSE: C - News) arranged an unusual financing technique for Enron Corp. ( ENRNQ) that enabled the energy trader to appear rich in cash rather than saddled with debt, Monday's Wall Street Journal reported, citing internal documents of both companies.
|
|||||||||||
Details of the controversial arrangement are only now coming to light as Congress turns to probing the role played by Enron's banks in enabling its illusory growth.
In a series of deals known as Yosemite, the documents show, Citigroup's complex scheme helped Enron borrow money over the past three years that was booked as coming from trades instead of loans. The deals, involving bond offerings and trades with an offshore entity, helped boost the company's weak cash flow to match its growth in paper profits, at a time when the gap between the two had grown to as much as $1 billion a year, according to one Enron memo.
Investigators want to determine whether Enron would have been able to defraud investors if not for the willing participation of Wall Street. The documents amount to the most in-depth evidence yet of the extent to which Citigroup, the nation's largest financial institution, helped Enron disguise debt on its balance sheet through some of the most complex financial accounting arrangements at the Houston energy company.
Although Citigroup's actions technically may have been in accordance with accounting principles, they raise questions over whether Citigroup helped shield important information from Enron investors. Citigroup says it has done nothing wrong, noting that lenders shouldn't be held responsible for how a client such as Enron accounted for the financing arranged by its bankers. Citigroup said in a statement, "The transactions we entered into with Enron were entirely appropriate at the time based on what we knew and what we were told by Enron. We were assured that Enron's auditors had approved them, and we believed they were consistent with accounting rules in place at the time." Enron officials did not return calls seeking comment.
The deals will be scrutinized in new detail as part of hearings the Senate's Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations will launch Tuesday, examining to what extent Enron's banks helped disguise the true nature of its finances until its spectacular flameout and filing for bankruptcy protection last December.
"It has become common knowledge that Enron engaged in accounting deceptions to convince lenders, investors and analysts that the company was in better financial shape than it was," said Senator Carl Levin, the Michigan Democrat who will act as co -chairman of the hearings. "The question the Subcommittee will examine is the extent to which major financial institutions knew of and aided Enron's accounting deceptions."
Citigroup rival J.P. Morgan (NYSE: JPM - News) Chase & Co . also will face scrutiny in the hearings this week for similar deals through a vehicle known as Mahonia, which was the subject of a page one story in The Wall Street Journal in January. Mahonia has drawn wide scrutiny following a lawsuit with insurers who guaranteed the transactions through surety bonds. The insurers refuse to pay Morgan, arguing that prepaid transactions effectively generated loans, not trades. Their viewpoint struck a chord with the judge overseeing the case, U.S. District Judge Jed S. Rakoff, who said in a March opinion that the Mahonia transactions "now appear to be nothing but a disguised loan."
The Securities and Exchange Commission ( news - web sites) is investigating both Citigroup and J.P. Morgan over whether the banks helped Enron hide debt and artificially boost cash flow, and the office of Manhattan District Attorney Robert Morgenthau also has been examining the deals, people familiar with the matter say. A spokesman for J.P. Morgan said the company believes "the prepaid transactions were properly accounted for by our firm and Enron."
Wall Street Journal Staff Reporters Jathon Sapsford and Paul Beckett contributed to this report.
Given both George Soros and the Goldman Sachs firm are buddy-buddies with the Clinton crowd, you wonder did they engage in fraudulent activity like the Clintons did. We know that it was Soros through his Quantum Fund that caused the Asian economic crisis of 1998-1999 due to manipulation of currency trades.
Robert E. Rubin is a Director, a Member of the Office of the Chairman of Citigroup Inc., and a member of the Citigroup Management Committee. He has been involved with financial markets and our nation's public policy debate all his professional life.
Mr. Rubin joined Citigroup on October 26, 1999, where he participates in the strategic, managerial and operational matters of the company. He also serves as a member of the Board of Directors of the Ford Motor Company. In March 2000, he became a member of the Advisory Board of Insight Capital Partners, a New York-based private-equity investment firm that specializes in e-commerce business-to-business companies.
______________________________
To Regain Confidence
By Robert E. Rubin
Sunday, July 21, 2002; Page B07
In my view, we need to restore the sound, broad-based strategy that was so central to the prosperity of the '90s. More specifically, I would focus especially on the following:
More... Robert Rubin speaks
___________________
April 9, 2002
Enron lawsuit portrays Rubin pushing bailout 
By Patrice Hill
THE WASHINGTON TIMES
Robert E. Rubin, the former Treasury secretary and current vice chairman of Citigroup Inc., is portrayed in the latest Enron lawsuit as trying to protect the bank's extensive investments in Enron Corp. by orchestrating a bailout for the energy giant in the fall. CONTINUE
Note to anyone in a customer-oriented business: Be very careful before you f#ck with the recent college graduate who doesn't have a nickel to his name -- He may never forgive you no matter how successful he becomes later in life.