Quite often, people who are opposed to a low carb way of eating will lecture you in this way because you scare them. They are addicted to their bread, pasta and cereal. The PC dogma over the past decade has provided them with the excuse to continue feeding their cravings and someone like you coming along is no different than a reformed alcoholic approaching a current alcoholic still in denial.
Someone mentioned Senator Pardek's cognitive dissonance. I noticed it too. The rabid anti-Atkins types pepper their disagreement with all kinds of hyperbolic, completley untrue statements about what low carbers advocate (eating a pound of bacon) and made up, yet unprovable "facts" or "facts" they know cannot be easily disputed (no pro Athletes eat an Atkins diet) in order to support their adherance to more mainstream dogma. The article in question does quite a bit to discredit the dogma and actually demonstrates that adherance to the dogma has not only failed to produce the health benefits it promises, but actually may have exacerbated the the very problems it claims to cure. Many of the posters here have done quite a bit to discuss the metabolic effects of a high carbohydrate diet, the impact that high carb diets have on hunger (an actually biological state as well as a mental one) and other aspects of the debate, but that is all ignored or simply dismissed as unimportant. It is far from unimportant. It is the basis and foundation of the debate itself!
For folks like Senator Pardek, it is much easier to spout off about will power or merely repeat the dogma that is being challenged as the unquestionable truth, than to actually examine the logic, science or even personal experiences of people posting here. His imagined "pro athlete" (which is most certainly a horrible basis for figuring out what makes sense for the rest of us) is all he needs to justify ignoring the actual debate and continuing to believe dogma.
LOL - nice rant - still waiting for proof of all the pro athletes who use that weird diet.
If your diet is based on losing weight, go Atkins - if it's based on becoming healthy - exercise, weight train, and eat 30% carbs!