Replies

The judge was appointed by Bush I...check it out yourself.

Well you McCainiacs are having trouble again with the facts, if you mean the Judge that wrote the decision. What part of the following do you not understand......

Profile of Judge Alfred T. Goodwin

Copyright and Trademark Notice | Disclaimer | Revised: 1/1/01
Use the Profile Comment Form to submit your own impressions for inclusion on this page.
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Appointed by: President Nixon, 1971

Profile of Judge Ferdinand F. Fernandez

Copyright and Trademark Notice | Disclaimer | Revised: 3/13/01
Use the Profile Comment Form to submit your own impressions for inclusion on this page.
Court: United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Appointed by: President Bush, 1989

Now do you want to still say the Judge that wrote the opinion was a Bush Appointee?

When all else fails, stun them with the facts. I have begun to realize just how ignorant some people are here. They claim to know all, but yet in fact, know just about nothing.

This is once again proven. Thanks for taking the time to get the facts out, correctly, about WHO the two judges were that made the ruling and the one judge who dissented. ;-) Deej

Well, okay, but ...both were Republican appointees. I still cannot see how you far-right-of-Josep Gobbels get off blaming McCain for the assinine ruling on the pledge; or how making it into a wedge issue for Bush appointments is going to help since, again, the judge was a Republic appointee. And another thing, McCain states in his book that he often led the pledge while a "guest" of the Hanoi Hilton. Incidentally, what was some of your hero "patriots" like Phil Gramm, Rush Limbaugh, or Mitch McConnell (all war age during the Korean and Vietnam eras) doing during that time?