Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

Skip to comments.

Is Paul McCartney worth $268.50?
Chicago Sun Times ^ | April 7, 2002 | Jim DeRogatis

Posted on 04/07/2002 2:09:32 PM PDT by ejdrapes

Is this man worth $268.50? April 7, 2002 BY JIM DeROGATIS POP MUSIC CRITIC

The frustrating thing about Paul McCartney is that he really should know better. As Chicago gears up to welcome Sir Paul to the United Center for two sold-out shows Wednesday and Thursday, some would argue (McCartney first among them) that it's unfair to compare his solo work to the group that made him an icon. The Beatles were a unique combination of extraordinary talents who arrived at a juncture when their impact transcended mere music (as influential as that was), and they have became inextricably linked with the vast social and cultural sea change of the '60s.

Time moves on, the '60s are history and fodder for endless nostalgic TV commercials, and we have now had Solo Paul (1970 to the present) for three times as long as we had Beatle Paul (the Quarry Men became the Silver Beetles in May 1960). But McCartney's solo output has been so famously and frustratingly uneven that a critic has to ask: Would anyone care about this guy if he hadn't once been a Mop Top?

The answer: Sure, to some extent. While he may not be the consummate pop craftsman that he'd have us believe (the Cole Porter or George Gershwin of his generation?), his ear for seductive melodies is undeniable. But his songs are often so slight, trifling, hyper-romantic, and shticky, his reputation would probably be akin that of Tom Jones if he'd never met and joined forces with John Lennon, once upon a time.

"What? Blasphemy!" scream the faithful. To which I reply: "Say Say Say," "Ebony and Ivory," "Silly Love Songs," "Listen to What the Man Said," "Magneto and Titanium Man," "Monkberry Moon Delight," "Oobu Joobu We Love You," "Getting Closer," "Old Siam Sir," "Let 'Em In," "Freedom," "Vanilla Sky"... to name but a few of his less than stellar moments.

The truth is, the roots of Macca's problems were there all through the Beatles. Yes, he recorded one of the strongest rock vocals ever ("I Saw Her Standing There"). And no, Lennon wasn't the group's only psychedelic groundbreaker and studio genius; "Helter Skelter," "Paperback Writer," "Fixing a Hole," "Penny Lane," "Eleanor Rigby," and "Magical Mystery Tour" were all McCartney at his best, and he made great contributions to "A Day in the Life" and "Baby, You're a Rich Man."

Macca could also be unbeatable when he was in romantic ballad mode. "For No One," "Here, There and Everywhere," and "Hey Jude" are timeless, beautiful, and much stronger songs than the more often-cited "Michelle" and "Yesterday," which are a bit too saccharine for my tastes.

Beatle Paul also gave us maudlin schlock ("She's Leaving Home"), reactionary turncoatism ("Lovely Rita" is, after all, a song in praise of ticket-writing cop--and this at the height of the Summer of Love!), and nostalgic nonsense ("When I'm Sixty-Four"). And on careful, honest examination sans the rose-colored glasses, alleged innovations such as the interlocking suites of songs on "Sgt. Pepper's" or the second side of "Abbey Road" are really a bunch of half-baked ideas strung together in place of full-born tunes.

The collaboration of the Beatles tended to diffuse or at least offset McCartney's worst tendencies. On his own, he's never really tried or dared to recruit backing bands up to the task of challenging or pushing him--witness Wings, or the current combo of generic Gen Xers joining him on the Driving USA tour. He has also made the deadly-to-all-great-art mistake of disconnecting or compromising whatever "B.S. detector" he once had, so that he now believes all his ideas are brilliant and equally worthy of our time.

Hence we get pompous silliness such as the foray into classical music with "The Liverpool Oratorio"; fabulous failures such as "Back to the Egg" and "Red Rose Speedway," and annoyingly cheesy throwaways such as "Loving Flame" and "There Must Have Been Magic" from the 2001 album, "Driving Rain."

The frustration sets in when we a catch a glimpse of something better and realize that McCartney could still be capable of greatness, if only he cared enough to strive a little bit harder.

Overall, "Driving Rain" is a solid if un-earthshaking pop effort, as was 1997's "Flaming Pie," though that album also boasted its share of stinkers. "Run Devil Run," his fiery 1999 set of '50s covers, is his finest recent offering, thanks to his level of passion for the tunes and a supporting cast that was actually on his level. He should have asked Pink Floyd's David Gilmour and Deep Purple's Ian Paice to play on "Driving Rain"--though even talented peers tend to be dwarfed or overwhelmed by the looming Beatles myth. Remember his unremarkable collaborations with Elvis Costello and Michael Jackson?

In recent years, McCartney has made several odd but illuminating low-key detours into the underground. He recorded two unextraordinary but ambitious ambient house efforts as The Fireman (1994's "strawberries oceans ships forests" and 1998's "Rushes"), and he compiled the impressionistic pastiche of "Liverpool Sound Collage," which was then mixed by indie/electronic art-rockers Super Furry Animals.

If the bassist is aware of underground trends and the cutting edge of modern rock, why are his more hyped recordings so conservative? If he can still feel the rush of great rock a la "Run Devil Run," why does he play it so safe so much of the time on his own tunes? Where is the man who gave us "I Saw Her Standing There" and "Helter Skelter"?

Charming and lovable though his public persona may be, ego remains the artist's Achilles' Heel, and the saddest proof of this can be seen in the ticket prices for the current tour. McCartney is one of the richest men in pop-music history, thanks to the success of the Beatles and the enduring strength of their catalog. He does not need the money from the Driving USA tour, and there are no charity givebacks.

Yet the top ticket price for his shows in Chicago is $268.50, including Ticketmaster service fees for phone and Internet sales. The least expensive seats, in the highest tier of the United Center and with obstructed views, are $62. The other prices are $140.50 and $98.50.

Fans may be tempted to blame the promoters, Clear Channel Entertainment, but the fact is that McCartney set the price. He could have charged $25 a ticket, Clear Channel would have made the shows happen, and he and the promoter would have still made a heck of a lot of money. But with artists such as Madonna and Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young selling seats at the high end of the spectrum, how would it look if a former Beatle wasn't commanding top dollar from his fans?

It's a bit hard to swallow Sir Paul in a fireman's T-shirt singing about our God-given right to live in freedom when you realize that rare indeed is the fireman or other working Joe in this country who can afford a night out with his wife that will easily cost him $600 or more, once you factor in parking and a babysitter. Free? Hardly!

Then again, at the Beatles' Royal Variety Performance in 1963, it was Lennon, not McCartney, who famously cracked, "Those of you in the cheaper seats can clap. The rest of you just rattle your jewelry."

They saw him standing there Chicagoans Patti Kunz, Linda Cerqua, and Angie Albano first saw Paul McCartney in concert on Sept. 5, 1964. The 13-year-olds sat in the third row of the International Amphitheatre and were captured in a famous Sun-Times photo illustrating the frenzied height of Beatlemania.

Thirty-eight years later, a lot has changed in the women's lives. But they are still friends and still big McCartney fans (though only two of them were lucky enough to score tickets to this week's concert). I asked them about their fandom then and now.

Q. How were you three lucky enough to get Beatles tickets in '64?

Cerqua: Back then, the only way you could get tickets was to send in your money and they picked winners like a lottery.

Kunz: I think the tickets cost like $7.50. I have the stubs.

Q. OK, take off the rose-colored glasses: How good was that concert, really?

Cerqua: Oh, of course they were wonderful!

Kunz: They were so good! I remember John Lennon looking right at us. We were throwing little balls of paper up on the stage with our phone numbers. You can see them in the picture.

Q. It's been said that fans couldn't even hear the music over the screaming. Is that true?

Cerqua: It was a lot of screaming and crying, and you can see by our picture that we were doing the same thing. But I remember their music; they sang "She Loves You," "I Wanna Hold Your Hand," all the earlier Beatles songs, and everyone knew all the words. We were close, in the third row, so maybe we heard better. But it was like they were singing to us.

Albano: There was a lot of screaming, but you could hear them, and they were wonderful. When Paul sang "Yesterday" [the next time we say the Beatles here in 1966], there was silence, and I heard every word. I was a John Lennon fan, but everyone knew Paul was the cutest.

Q. Solo Paul vs. Beatle Paul--do you think he measures up?

Cerqua: Well, back then, he was like an idol. Now, I look at him as a musician. I've been to his solo concerts, and of course I thought he was great. But he still did a lot of Beatles songs, and when he does those, it just hits something special.

Albano: When he went into Wings, I thought he was pretty great. I just think he's so talented, and everything about him is good.

Q. How do you feel about him charging a top price of $268.50 for these tickets?

Cerqua: I don't understand it. He has so much money. When I heard he was coming, I was thinking, "There's no way I can afford that." But Angie got two tickets for her birthday from her brother. He's a lawyer and his firm gets tickets.

Albano: I don't understand why the tickets are this price. I didn't think any group that plays at the United Center was getting this kind of money. But I think the people who are really big fans are gonna be there no matter what.

Kunz: The prices are why I'm not going: We can't afford it. I mean, we could, but ... not really. He used to have a fan club, back when Linda was alive. I sent money to that, and when he came last time, maybe 10 years ago, anybody who was in the club, he gave the tickets away for almost nothing. I got third row again, and I got to see him play in Milwaukee Stadium, which was excellent. I thought, "Boy, he was doing pretty good back then." Now, I'm thinking, "What the heck happened? He must be so rich, and I didn't hear that he's giving it away to charity!"


TOPICS: News/Current Events
KEYWORDS:
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-80, 81-93 next last
I love how at the very end of this article the guy finally gets to his main gripe: McCartney is wealthy enough, he doesn't need to charge these kind of prices (regardless if his peers are charging the same), and SHOCK, it doesn't appear that any of the proceeds are going to charity (although how would he know if they were anyway?). It all comes back to this liberal orthodoxy...he's "wealthy enough". It's not up to me, or this music critic or anyone else to decide how much money someone should make, or how wealthy someone can become. McCartney hasn't screwed anyone over - he hasn't forced anyone to buy his records or attend his concerts. He's obviously a very shrewd business man who created a vast fortune. I say more power to him!
1 posted on 04/07/2002 2:09:32 PM PDT by ejdrapes
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes
McCartney RULES....he has made the LIBERALS really MAD....ever since 9/11 when he went on record AGAINST the terrorists (I heard it with my own ears from some libs - they called him a "sell-out!")
2 posted on 04/07/2002 2:14:02 PM PDT by goodnesswins
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes
$286.50?? I do believe my bank account beats the hell out of that.
3 posted on 04/07/2002 2:14:17 PM PDT by dc-zoo
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes
Paul ROCKS !!!
4 posted on 04/07/2002 2:15:01 PM PDT by The Giant Apricots
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes
If he charges less he lowers the overall market value of the lesser stars. Lets say he charged 10 dollars. That poor minimum wage guitar player at the local pub certainly isn't worth ten dollars if McCartney only charged ten dollars is he ?
5 posted on 04/07/2002 2:23:16 PM PDT by VRWC_minion
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes
The problem of the high ticket prices can be solved by market forces if enough people would do what I do: say "That's ridiculous, I'm not paying that much money for a couple of hours of music!" and don't go.

I also disagree with him on McCartney's collaboration with Elvis Costello. I thought it was the best thing Paul had done in years, maybe because Elvis' nasty intelligence provided the same sort of chemistry that Lennon provided. And the song Elvis recorded that he wrote with McCartney, "Veronica," is one of his best, IMHO.

6 posted on 04/07/2002 2:39:33 PM PDT by HHFi
[ Post Reply]

To: goodnesswins
I have been a Beatle fan since "I Want to Hold Your Hand" and married a nutzoid Beatle fan who saw them in concert in LA on 8/28/66 (I believe her)and has kept a scrapbook of every newspaper article about them (individually too) since then. She saw Paul in concert in Boulder CO and together we've seen Ringo in concert twice. Though together we've spent some bucks on all their recordings including videos there is no way it adds up to the thousands and thousands of hours of pure enjoyment of listening to their music as Beatles and individually through the years. And we're going to spend $600 to see the 20th century Mozart LIVE in concert!
7 posted on 04/07/2002 2:39:44 PM PDT by jwh_Denver
[ Post Reply]

To: VRWC_minion
McCartney is not worth more than $ 50.00. He is NOT a band he is only Paul. 50% of the Beatles have gone and The Stones are still rockin" . THEY are worth $268.00 and will rock you from beginning to end. I can't fathom how anyone would pay those prices to see only 1/4 of the original Beatles .. Can't wait for the Stone summer tour -2002-
8 posted on 04/07/2002 2:42:45 PM PDT by Renegade
[ Post Reply]

Comment #9 Removed by Moderator

To: ejdrapes
Paul must be doing something(s) right.

1. Sold out.

2. A lot (LOT) of free publicity from the Sun Times.
Well, maybe not free, maybe comp tickets?

T

My late GrandMom would have paid $268 for this show. So would Grampaw. He paid for Hollywood Bowl tickets when the Beatles first went to L.A. and that was the start of one helluva' marriage.
I wonder how many other oldsters, now that they can afford it, are going just to reminisce, regardless of what he sounds like now?

10 posted on 04/07/2002 2:44:00 PM PDT by AzJP
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes
$268.50? How dare he charge nearly half as much as Barbra Streisand for a concert.
11 posted on 04/07/2002 2:48:01 PM PDT by Vince Ferrer
[ Post Reply]

To: mortsahl
mortsahl

Mort Sahl?

Gramps just had an out of body experience. Any relation to the sweatered comic? Grampaw still has an original 33 1/3 vinyl disk.

12 posted on 04/07/2002 2:48:41 PM PDT by AzJP
[ Post Reply]

To: ALL;ejdrapes
FREEPERS COME OVER HERE AND HELP OUT
THE CITIZENS FOR MEDICAL ISOTOPES Thanks

While you are there please read posting #156 very powerful and e-mail
this URL to all your friends and family who would not see it otherwise.
http://www.medicalisotopes.org

13 posted on 04/07/2002 2:49:32 PM PDT by Spunky
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes
He's worth it if people will pay. I paid $108 per ticket for CSN&Y, until I came to my senses and sold it. But for Paul, I might spring for it. You know, it's not just Paul making the money, there are many hands in the pot, the unions don't help. Good luck to Sir Paul.
14 posted on 04/07/2002 2:49:41 PM PDT by Hildy
[ Post Reply]

Comment #15 Removed by Moderator

To: cplboyle
What a pompous windbag!!!

And you're a tin eared, no nothing fool.

16 posted on 04/07/2002 3:01:25 PM PDT by eddie willers
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes;BluesDuke
Anyone that likes "Helter Skelter" and doesn't even mention "She's A Woman" ain't much of a music reviewer.

The rest is liberal whining.

17 posted on 04/07/2002 3:03:33 PM PDT by eddie willers
[ Post Reply]

To: Hildy
I think the tickets cost like $7.50. I have the stubs.

I have a pair of those, too!

18 posted on 04/07/2002 3:05:28 PM PDT by Howlin
[ Post Reply]

To: AzJP
I dearly LOVE Mort Sahl.
19 posted on 04/07/2002 3:06:34 PM PDT by Howlin
[ Post Reply]

To: ejdrapes
As someone who lived through the beatles' wretched excesses, let me say two things about those silly enough to still idolize the "fab four": Those my age quite obviously killed far too many brain cells while enjoying the beatles' cacaphony to now be capable of rational judgement. Those younger than me need to kill some brain cells in order to spare the rest of us having to endure your sheer idolic idiocy.

The beatles were a mediocre group of thin-voiced guitar strummers (other than ringo who poorly banged the drums)who had the good fortune to come along right when an entire generation rendered themselves so incoherently drugged out that they became somnolently suseptible to any and all foolishness liberals decreed to be "in with the in crowd."

To those who insist upon pointing to the one or two actually melodic songs these musical midgets wrote, I suggest that if you give four monkeys a couple of keyboards and several years to play with them, the primates would have a far more impressive output.

20 posted on 04/07/2002 3:09:10 PM PDT by elwoodp
[ Post Reply]


Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-80, 81-93 next last

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.

Free Republic
Browse · Search
News/Activism
Topics · Post Article

FreeRepublic, LLC, PO BOX 9771, FRESNO, CA 93794
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson