[hobbes1]

In either case that is what I was getting at. Though when I looked today, at their wbsite, thought that there were more Reagan/Bush.

[45Auto]

I think of the 20 justices that sit on the 5th Circuit, 11 are Reagan-Bush Sr. and 9 are Carter-Clinton. The Emerson case was heard by a three-judge panel with two being 'conservative' and one being 'liberal'. The court's opinion in Emerson was written mostly by Garwood, a gun-owner and keen historian of the 2nd. I'd like to see Garwood nominated to the SC.