Skip to comments.
Why the Muslims Misjudged Us
Opinion Journal ^
| 02/25/2002
| VICTOR DAVIS HANSON
Posted on 02/24/2002 8:09:51 PM PST by Pokey78
Edited on 04/23/2004 12:04:14 AM PDT by Jim Robinson.
[history]
Since September 11, we have heard mostly slander and lies about the West from radical Islamic fundamentalists in their defense of the terrorists. But the Middle Eastern mainstream--diplomats, intellectuals and journalists--has also bombarded the American public with an array of unflattering images and texts, suggesting that the extremists' anti-Americanism may not be an eccentricity of the ignorant but rather a representative slice of the views of millions.
(Excerpt) Read more at opinionjournal.com ...
TOPICS: Culture/Society; Editorial
KEYWORDS: clashofcivilizatio
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-67 next last
To: Pokey78
bttt
41
posted on
02/25/2002 6:02:53 AM PST
by
summer
To: Pokey78
The fact is that democracy does not spring fully formed from the head of Zeus but rather is an epiphenomenon--the formal icing on a pre-existing cake of egalitarianism, economic opportunity, religious tolerance and constant self-criticism. If we had never had the American Revolution we might be like Canada ar Australia. Perhaps not as grand as we are now, but worse things could have happened. Our ideas are build of two thousand plus years of thought. Islam is built on the rejection of that 2000 years.
42
posted on
02/25/2002 6:18:01 AM PST
by
js1138
To: eclectic
"The Muslims might have misjudged America, but America has yet a long way to go to prove how wrong they are indeed." Yeah.
But my answer: the Muslims misjudged us because they thought we were as weak, naive and ineffectual as Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter.
--Boris
43
posted on
02/25/2002 6:21:11 AM PST
by
boris
To: matamoros
Fire is not necessary. The blood of 10,000 pigs should suffice.
--Boris
44
posted on
02/25/2002 6:23:49 AM PST
by
boris
To: Pokey78
bookmark
45
posted on
02/25/2002 6:24:16 AM PST
by
medved
To: boris
Bump
46
posted on
02/25/2002 6:26:09 AM PST
by
Mahone
Comment #47 Removed by Moderator
To: Pokey78 ;Thinkin' Gal ;veronica;dennisw;TrueBeliever9; Prodigal Daughter; Zadokite;babylonian...
If Israel were not so successful, free and haughty--if it were beleaguered and tottering on the verge of ruin--perhaps it would be tolerated. But in a sea of totalitarianism and government-induced poverty, a relatively successful economy and a stable culture arising out of scrub and desert clearly irks its less successful neighbors. Envy, as the historian Thucydides reminds us, is a powerful emotion and has caused not a few warYEP!An act of God!
Excellent article..a ping to others
48
posted on
02/25/2002 6:41:16 AM PST
by
RnMomof7
To: McGavin999
his is something else the Muslims don't realize about us. We are very, very slow to anger but once we do, we don't forgive easily.Winston Churchill said something like that. He said that Americans were the slowest people in the world to finally get mad and the slowest to cool off afterwards. Of course, Winston was half-American himself.
49
posted on
02/25/2002 6:49:32 AM PST
by
xJones
To: boris
But my answer: the Muslims misjudged us because they thought we were as weak, naive and ineffectual as Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter.Yeppers, and if Clinton had somehow been President on 9/ll the Taliban would still be in power in Afghanistan with their al-Quida buddies. Osama's great mistake was one of timing.
50
posted on
02/25/2002 6:59:42 AM PST
by
xJones
To: Atlantin
Neither address the critical factor of mean IQ of populations except to dismiss it.They're just too stupid, I suppose.
Seriously, I oversimplified J. Diamond's argument, in order to express it a few words. You seem to argue for an "IQ" determinism. This seems silly given the rise and fall of civilizations over time. And since America is the most mongrel of civilizations, it's hard to believe that only the most intelligent emigrated here. The reason for the success of our culture is our embrace of freedom in economics, politics, and other social spheres, not an "average" ability to match 3-D projections.
51
posted on
02/25/2002 7:03:35 AM PST
by
Faraday
Absolutely brilliant. When Pat Roberstson criticized Islam recently and the drumbeat began in the media to demonize him for his opinion, it suddenly stopped and died.
Why? Because of the beheading of Danial Pearl who left a lovely pregnant wife and a future child who will never know his or her courageous INNOCENT father.
My Arab readers, while you may think Robertson impertinent for his remarks, I think your lack of outrage at the Pearl slaughter far more evil
To: Dec31,1999
Can you give examples of democratic nations in the past or present? Athens. Any state with a referendum.
53
posted on
02/25/2002 7:33:59 AM PST
by
Demidog
To: Pokey78
There is one simpler consideration, and it is that for some years now "Death to America" has been an all-pervasive motto (and this predates the 1979 Iranian revolution considerably) in the Islamic world. Authorities have allowed this to run essentially unchecked as a means of easing social control: every despot ever born realizes that an external enemy is necessity number one for distracting an oppressed population. Nobody in the ruling elites was taking it very seriously; a few dead Americans in isolated terror incidents was, to them, nothing more than a morale-booster for their population.
Now we're 3000-odd people down. And we're taking it seriously. And not only our enemies, for such they are, but our putative allies, are acting as if we're spoiling some silly international game by taking it seriously, as if shrugging off an attack leaving thousands of dead is the mark of some sort of sophistication.
Well, all of the old rhetorical ammunition is being trotted out - the U.S. is a "rogue state," we're "terrorists," "out of control," "imperialists," etc, etc...we've heard it all before. If there ever was a time when it mattered, and I submit that under Carter and Clinton, it did, then it certainly doesn't matter any longer. The uneasiness we're hearing from the European left is a result of their realization that the same old BS just isn't cutting it any more.
Comment #55 Removed by Moderator
To: darlin'
ping
To: Demidog
The formal machinery of a democratic government is 2 wolves and a sheep voting over what's for dinner. If "the Muslims" (nebulous and useless term) have been devoid of democracy, they should consider themselves lucky.
Can you name a better form of government? Perhaps you would like to live in Iraq? Iran? Communist China?
To: Michael2001
Of course I can name a better form of government. A republic. Where do you think you live? You think you live in a democracy?
58
posted on
02/25/2002 6:02:07 PM PST
by
Demidog
To: eclectic
We don't have to actively prove how wrong they are. Our very existence and ultimate success does that by itself.
59
posted on
02/25/2002 6:04:43 PM PST
by
Parmy
Comment #60 Removed by Moderator
Navigation: use the links below to view more comments.
first previous 1-20, 21-40, 41-60, 61-67 next last
Disclaimer:
Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual
posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its
management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the
exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson