I see the first chapter as providing background into the character of hobbits. They may be "tough as dragons in a pinch" but they don't like being put in pinches. They like getting proper meals and smoking pipeweed without Big Folk bothering them.
So when our heroes have to go on their adventure, we know that this is not the way things usually are for hobbits, and it makes what they do all the more impressive.
Also, this chapter is mostly light-hearted, but there are a few moments where the new, darker tone of the book creeps through, like when Bilbo doesn't want to give away the Ring. This is also to clue us in that there's something odd here, as readers of The Hobbit will find Bilbo's behavior very odd.
Nice idea. Count me in as a frequent visitor to the tavern.
I have always thought that this chapter served as the (necessary) transition from The Hobbit to LOTR. It has some of the feel of The Hobbit and of course traffics in familiar characters and places. It's very "hobbity."
The prose is a little deeper, however, and hints creep in quickly that despite all the fun, that this will be a darker tale.
But I suppose my Gaffer would say that's what comes of mixing in the affairs of your betters.
I'm partway through the Two Towers and love it. I'm taking my dad to see the movie this weekend (it'll be my third viewing). This thread is a great idea--thanks!!!
Note to self: get to work...step away from the LOTR sites...
I'm pretty busy at work most of the time, but would appreciate being on the ping list. Maybe I can catch up and add a thought or two at odd hours after work and weekends....
May I be added to this fellowship too, please?