[Aggie Mama]

I thought he renounced his citizenship. How can he have Constitutional rights if he's not a citizen?

[AmericanInTokyo]

The media keeps saying : "...., who fought alongside the Taliban".

I don't hear them say much about: "...., who joined the terrorist al-Qaida network." Anyone else notice that?

[piasa]

He did not renounce his citizenship- if he did there would be a file with the documents and signd oath of renouncement in some US embassy or consulate office in Pakistan or Yemen.

As for violating the fine print on citizenship on a US passport, there are reasons not to take his citizenship based on that that would set up an awkward precedent, I think, in the way we would have to treat other members of al-Qeada.

[Cletus.D.Yokel]

Ever read the fine print in a US passport?

Don't have mine with me but what does it say about "taking up arms" (fighting along side the enemy) against the US? If someone has it, please repro the verbage here. It is relevant.