Naah, not enough age difference between Shatner and Philbin. Perhaps Adam Sandler as Frodo? Ouch, that mental image stings!
I'm not sure. If certain people had their way, Haley Joel "I see dead people" Osment would be Frodo, either him of the "little hot shot" from Episode I.
Hey! That's right! What were we thinking?! As Frodo, we could have JarJar Binks!