[Arkinsaw]

All of your posts on the subject seem to indicate a verbal battle between kindly anti-Potter grandmas and hateful vindictive pro-Potter/pro-witchcraft mobs. Where the anti-Potter folks were interested in a gentle and thorough debate on the merits and drawbacks of the Potter books but that those discussions never bore fruit because they were stopped cold by anti-Potterites who desired no rational debate.

That sounds lovely, and it is certainly an interesting perspective. But its not what happened on Potter threads.

[Dr. Eckleburg]

Sounds about right to me. :@)