In Cuba, a revolution is over

If you’ve ever thought of visiting the crocodile-shaped island of Cuba, or run into someone recently returned from sultry nights in the country’s salsa halls, there’s a good chance you’ll have heard the phrase “See it before it changes.” And I don’t mean because of Hurricane Melissa.

The idea is that the centrally planned communist state, one of the last on Earth, will soon morph into America and a balmy Brigadoon full of people unencumbered by money, modern cars or Alexa will evaporate.

I think most people, if they knew what Cubans have endured, wouldn’t use that phrase, which is up there in its lack of tact with “they’re poor but they’re happy.”

But shortly after I arrived on the Caribbean island almost eight years ago, the same idea was put to me by a Cuban, although in a different way. She asked: “When does a revolution end?” That’s a question that has stayed with me. I remember my sweaty journey in from Havana’s José Martí International Airport that January 2018 evening.

Having visited the island regularly before, on the cusp of turning 50 I’d come for a three-month break. I’m still here, married, with a four-year-old son.

The roadside billboards advertised nothing other than the government’s answer to my friend’s question: “¡Hasta la victoria siempre!” (An imperfect translation: “Until the eternal victory.”)

At the time, the country was still enjoying a great burst of hope that had begun in 2016, when then-US president Barack Obama flew in to “bury the last remnant of the Cold War.” The Rolling Stones played and Chanel used Havana as a catwalk.

Yet, the city still had rebel undercurrents that I remembered from earlier visits, a population of offbeat expats, some on the run from the US authorities. There were fraudsters and rogue CIA agents, Black Panthers and South and Central American liberation fighters – or terrorists, depending on your point of view.

It was still easy to meet Cubans who, if critical of the day-to-day work of the government, supported the Castro brothers’ grand project. The young intellectuals, the artists and musicians, were often offended by the abuse being thrown across the Florida Straits by the exile community in Miami.

The older generation were even more bonded to the revolution. Having answered Che Guevara’s call to subsume personal ambition to the common good, they were living on the promised reward of free healthcare and food. The government, however, which controlled everything including the importation of food, was low on funds, a situation soon worsened by the Covid pandemic. Shortages cut in, with days-long lines for essentials. Botched economic reforms then saw inflation take hold and pensions and wages reduced, in real terms, to what is now less than $10 a month.

Soon many people were pondering when a revolution ends. In July 2021, protests erupted and were put down with force. Private entrepreneurs were given permission to import food, sold at prices far beyond what most people could pay. The rations of rice, sugar and beans distributed by state bodegas faltered.

While there have always been people who go through the street-corner rubbish bins, their numbers blossomed. Older people, their dignity still showing in their neat if frayed clothes, began to ask for money from other Cubans on the street. The fumigators who used to demand access to your house to spray for mosquitoes disappeared. A grand exodus began, with estimates of up to 18 percent of the population leaving for the US, Latin America, Spain and oddly – due to a lack of visa restrictions – Serbia. Some fools even went to Russia to fight against Ukraine. The obsolescent electricity grid collapsed, again and again, and the water system with it. Power cuts have become a fact of life.

I live a far more privileged life than most of my neighbors, but I find the water shortages hard. Nothing spells “¡Hasta la victoria siempre!” like glancing up to see your child pooping on the floor when you haven’t had running water for two days. But, like the frog in boiling water (lucky him), somehow we seem to get used to it. It’s not easy. As I write, the awful Hurricane Melissa, which caused chaos in Jamaica, carried on through Cuba’s east, bringing landslides, flooding and misery.

Meanwhile, there is an outbreak of chikungunya fever, spread by the mosquitos that the state can no longer afford to spray against. (Chikungunya means “contortion” in Tanzanian Makonde, and is as much fun as it sounds.) Yet, to my surprise, I still feel that same thrill as I take the sweaty journey in from the airport, past the increasingly faded slogans on the billboards, through this city of crumbling grandeur, to what’s become my home, looking forward to being among the Cubans once more. This is what I hope to write about in this column as we move forward.

So, when does a revolution end? I was talking to my Cuban friend again, blathering on about how her question could currently be asked of the American Revolution. But she remained focused on Cuba’s own, saying: “Maybe it’s already over, and we just haven’t noticed it.”

Message from Jim Robinson:

Dear FRiends,

We need your continuing support to keep FR funded. Your donations are our sole source of funding. No sugar daddies, no advertisers, no paid memberships, no commercial sales, no gimmicks, no tax subsidies. No spam, no pop-ups, no ad trackers.

If you enjoy using FR and agree it's a worthwhile endeavor, please consider making a contribution today:

Click here: to donate by Credit Card

Or here: to donate by PayPal

Or by mail to: Free Republic, LLC - PO Box 9771 - Fresno, CA 93794

Thank you very much and God bless you,

Jim

Mayor Karen Bass: Don’t give up, comrades. I will come to fight alongside you again. And we have socialists undermining the corrupt capitalist empire here even was we speak.

Bass made eight trips to Cuba as a member of the Venceremos Brigade, a group that organized annual trips to Cuba for young Americans. During this time she was educated in methods of making revolutions.

She accompanied John Kerry and then Barack Obama as relations became healed with Cuba and an American flag was allowed to be raised over the US Embassy, a ceremony Bass attended.

During these trips, she participated in building houses and other work, which she described as a way to help the Cuban people.
2011: Traveled to Havana as part of a trip sponsored by The Center for Democracy in the Americas.

Bass said when Castro died in November 2016 he was the “Comandante en Jefe,” a phrase Castro’s government used to praise him.

Been there, and the only value I see in going is for more people to see how miserably socialism fails in practice. (Side note: I'm currently transitting funds there for a dissident pastor to buy a car, and he just got over the illness mentioned in the article. Sounds like a painful one.)

The only thing I saw that was new and shiny there in my travels were "Vive la Revolution!" posters featuring huge portraits of the long-dead Fidel Castro. 60+ years and the communist government was still acting like it was the outsider bringing change, rather than the institution that was in power and fossilizing without any plan to fix anything. The current leaders have no charisma and no support, so no point in putting them on the posters. The whole regime is running on fumes.

The people sat on their hands on the curb; if they actually try to do anything, like, say, starting a food stand, the secret police will accuse of them being "capitalist exploiters" or worse. So they sit on their hands, and slowly starve.

Even now that Cuba has gotten worse, the true believers are probably still true believing. The socialist idea is like a cockroach. It gets stomped on again and again by reality but keeps scurrying around in people’s minds. That’s why I don’t think it’s a slam dunk that NYC will learn the right lesson from Mamdani.

https://havanatimes.org/features/todays-average-cuban-salary-now-equals-us-16-per-month/
Average salary $16 per month at the “black market” exchange rate.

https://tradingeconomics.com/brazil/wages
Average salary in Brazil 3500 reals per month which is about $660. The exchange rate of 5.3 reals per dollar is a market exchange rate, the government does not attempt to control it.

$10/month. What should we do? Pay everyone $15 a month and they all work for us. What would we want them to do?

We could totally modernize the country in 10 years. Too much too soon?

A Swedish friend of mine vacationed in Cuba recently. He explained that he hired an escort for a week. Stunning Hispanic brunette.

Cost him $100 for six days of companionship.

She was making five times what a doctor makes in Cuba.

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.