Explainer: Israeli Far Right Lawmakers Defending Soldiers Accused of Raping Palestinian Prisoner

New Delhi: The deep fissures in Israeli society came out in the open this week when a mob of lawmakers and far right groups stormed an Israeli base where soldiers accused of raping a Palestinian prisoner are being held pending their trial.

Some Israelis have called it one of their most distressing days, while right-wing Israeli lawmakers, including those from the ruling Likud, have justified the rape of Hamas prisoners, claiming it is legitimate due to the atrocities committed during the October 7 attacks, which Israel says resulted in approximately 1,200 deaths:

“A member of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s Likud party, speaking Monday at a meeting of lawmakers, justified the rape and abuse of Palestinian prisoners, shouting angrily at colleagues questioning the alleged behavior that anything was legitimate to do to “terrorists” in custody.

Lawmaker Hanoch Milwidsky was asked as he defended the alleged abuse whether it was legitimate, “to insert a stick into a person’s rectum?”

“Yes!” he shouted in reply to his fellow parliamentarian. “If he is a Nukhba [Hamas militant], everything is legitimate to do! Everything!”

The disagreement escalated dramatically on Monday when military police officers detained nine soldiers at Sde Teiman on suspicion of raping a Palestinian detainee and subsequently transferred them to Beit Lid, another military base.

The arrests came against the wider backdrop of the International Criminal Court considering a request by its prosecutor for Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and others to be prosecuted for war crimes.

On July 29, Israeli military police detained at least nine military reservists at Sde Teiman military base, which had been the focus of several leaked investigations for its treatment of Palestinian prisoners.

According to reports, the Israeli military has said that the soldiers are being questioned as part of a probe into “suspected substantial sexual abuse of a detainee”. A lawyer, Nati Rom, representing three of the soldiers had told media that the charges were for committing “acts of sodomy”. He also claimed that the prisoner was a high-ranking Hamas militant.

As per Associated Press, the lawyer Rom works for Honenu, a nationalist legal group that specializes in defending Israeli soldiers and civilians facing prosecution over incidents of violence with Palestinians.

Several Israeli media outlets reported that the prisoner had been hospitalized with a serious injury to his intimate parts. Haaretz reported that he had “ruptured bowel, a severe injury to his anus, lung damage and broken ribs”.

“If the state and Knesset members think there’s no limit to how much you can abuse prisoners, they should kill them themselves, like the Nazis did, or close the hospitals,” Yoel Donchin, a doctor who treated the Palestinian prisoner, told the Israeli media outlet.

Haaretz reported that the confrontation escalated between military police personnel and soldiers who refused to evacuate and barricaded themselves inside the facility. According to security sources, some soldiers reportedly used pepper spray against the military personnel who arrived to detain the suspects.

As news of the soldiers’ questioning spread, a large group of around 200 protesters, including at least three Knesset lawmakers, gathered outside in protest against the detention and eventually broke into the base.

The masked protesters shouted, “We will not abandon our friends, certainly not for terrorists.”

The prominent politicians in the crowd, included Heritage Minister Amichai Eliyahu, Otzma Yehudit MK and MK Zvi Sukkot of the Religious Zionism, member of the ruling coalition.

The Times of Israel noted that Sukkot says in a video that “we cannot investigate the soldiers until we investigate those who failed” to prevent October 7.

He is also filmed leading a group of protestors to the gate of the base and forcing his way through. On reaching the detention centre within the base, videos show the protestors attempting to break down the gates.

It was only then that the police arrived at the base, who then push the protestors outside the base.

The protestors then moved later on Monday night to a second base, Beit Lid, where the detained soldiers were being held. It houses offices of the military court and military police. The Times of Israel reported that some of the protestors at Beit Lid, seemed to be armed and wore IDF uniforms.

On Tuesday, the Israeli military indicted a reservist posted at Sde Teiman base in a separate case for using “severe violence against the detainees he was entrusted with guarding”.

Sde Teiman is an Israeli military base located in the Negev desert. Since the start of Israel’s military invasion of Gaza following Hamas’ October 7 terror attack, the base has also been used as a detention centre.

Satellite images analysed by CNN revealed significant changes at the base after October 7, including the addition of more than 100 new structures, such as tents and hangars, and an increase in the number of vehicles

There have been multiple investigations, from media outlets like CNN, The New York Times, Associated Press, BBC and Haaretz, which have thrown up concerns about serious human rights violations against Palestinian prisoners.

The IDF had announced a probe into the allegations of sexual abuse at Sde Teiman, as well as two other military detention camps at Anatot and Ofer.

Based on these media investigations, Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) had filed a petition with Israel’s High Court of Justice to close the detention centre at the Sde Teiman military base in May.

At the first hearing, the Israeli government had said that it was phasing out the detention centre at Sde Teiman by transferring Palestinian prisoners to other military facilities.

The Israeli Defense Forces stated, according to Israeli media, that the storming of the two bases was directly compromising Israel’s security as it had caused a “major distraction” from retaliatory actions against Hezbollah in Lebanon.

Top IDF officers, including Chief of Staff Lieutenant General Herzi Halevi, halted discussions on the retaliation to address the base infiltrations. Halevi also visited the Beit Lid base, reported the Times of Israel.

Meanwhile, additional soldiers were deployed from the West Bank and recalled from vacation to the Beit Lid base.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu “strongly condemned” the storming of the bases, while Israeli president Isaac Herzog claimed that the “morality of the IDF and its soldiers have always been our pride”.

“Let us not forget that our enemies try to go after us again and again, also in the international legal arena … It is forbidden in any way to give them grounds [to go after] the IDF and the State of Israel,” he said.

Defence Minister Yoav Gallant said that while he was in “full appreciation for the soldiers who carry out the complex and important task of imprisoning Hamas terrorists,”, the law will apply to everyone, “even if angry”.

He also demanded an investigation into whether far-right National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir had “prevented or delayed the police response” to the riots.

The Jerusalem Post, citing sources, stated that the police was furious with the military for “not adequately inform(ing) them about the scale of the incident”.

Israeli opposition leader Yair Lapid claimed that the storming of the bases was “an attempted coup by an armed militia against a weak prime minister who is unable to control his government.”

“A dangerous fascist group threatens the existence of the State of Israel. They are the best thing that happened to [Gaza ruler Yahya] Sinwar and [Hezbollah chief Hassan] Nasrallah. If we don’t stand up to them, the country will fall apart. If Netanyahu does not fire the ministers who participated in these violent raids today, he is not fit to represent the State of Israel,” Lapid said in a statement.

Meanwhile, several members of the ruling coalition criticized the arrest of the nine soldiers.

“I recommend the defense minister, the IDF chief, and the military authorities to back the fighters and learn from the prison service – light treatment of terrorists is over. Soldiers need to have our full support,” said Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir.

Justice Minister Yariv Levin said he was “shocked to see harsh pictures of soldiers being arrested.”

“The excessive motivation to act against IDF fighters raises difficult questions. It seems that the wheels of justice at the military advocate’s office are turning in the opposite direction,” stated Economy Minister Nir Barkat. “They are justified, and I support them with all my heart,” said Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich in a statement, but adding that his supporters should not to break into IDF bases or engage in scuffles with soldiers and police officers.

Far-right parliamentarian Limor Son Har-Melech posted a video on X showing her addressing the detained soldiers at Sde Teiman and referring to the “criminal military advocate.”

The far-right lawmakers who stormed the bases also posted videos of interviews with masked members of Force 100, the unit to which the detained soldiers at Sde Teiman belonged.

There was demand from some Palestinian officials for an international probe for probing the allege crimes against Palestinian detainees.

Mustafa Barghouti, a member of the Palestinian Legislative Council, said that the IDF was trying protect itself from the International Criminal Court by conducting a formal investigation, but even that does not please “Israeli fascists”.

Qadura Fares, a former minister who heads the Palestinian Prisoners Club, called for the establishment of a UN investigation committee to scrutinize the conditions of Palestinian prisoners, especially at Sde Teiman, as well as other facilities where sexual assaults are alleged. He dismissed the arrests of several soldiers by the Israeli military police as a “farce” designed to deceive international public opinion.

One of the reporters covering the riots at the base, Ynet News’s Ilana Curiel, narrated her harrowing experience, when the mob turned upon her.

“Traitor. Wh*re. Go back to Gaza. Hamas. These are just some of the insults hurled at me and other journalists who came to cover the protest at the entrance to the IDF detention center at Sde Teiman. This doesn’t include the spitting, additional colourful curses, and shoving that took place,” she wrote.

Ilana Curiel stated that she wasn’t afraid on October 7, and neither had she cried while reporting on the aftermath of the Hamas attack. But, she was afraid of protestors at Sde Teiman. “The feeling that I was afraid of Israelis, of people who are supposed to be my neighbors, of people who are part of my nation. You’re supposed to be the ones I expect to stand by my side. We’re supposed to be together in all this, right?

Amid growing concerns about the unchecked rise of the far-right in Israel under the Netanyahu government’s reliance on extremist parties, Haaretz columnist Chaim Levinson referred to the incident as an “Altalena moment.” This refers to the 1948 IDF attack on the ship Altalena, which was carrying weapons for a Jewish paramilitary group, resulting in 19 deaths.

“Are there militias with political affiliations here doing whatever they want, or is there a central authority subject to the law and chain of command?” he posted. Levinson noted that the Altalena battle was decided in favor of the state, but the conflict over Sde Teiman will be decided in favor of the far right. “The authority of the army will be dismantled,” he added.

The lead editorial in Haaretz on July 31 noted that the far right poses a threat to ordinary Israelis.

“The mob that broke into two IDF bases, accompanied by MKs from the governing coalition, is another red line that has been crossed. The far right is ratcheting up a notch. If the authorities don’t come down hard on the protesters – including the MKs and ministers who supported them – then what happened on Monday will enter the far-right’s repertoire of political violence. If the state doesn’t employ the full force of the law against them, they will become a real threat to ordinary Israelis, judges, opposition MKs, army officers, journalists and anyone else they mark as targets,” noted the Haaretz editorial.

In a tweet, Ben-Ephraim said that the Israeli government had been lying so far when it had dismissed allegations of torture as ‘propaganda’ and has only acted now “because the pressure from the UK, ICC and ICJ was getting too great to ignore”:

I feel stupid and ashamed. In May, an expose came out on CNN detailing the abuses in Sde Taiman. Then, the NYT released their own article on it. Both were backed up with Israeli sources, crossed with Palestinian ones. I dismissed them because my government sources and Israeli media denied them. My whole life I was told that the international media was out to get Israel. That they were all antisemites.

But today, I realized how much I was lied to. By my country. By my friends. By my media. Today, many of the people I talked to who denied these allegations admitted they were true.

And the worst part? None of this is coming to light because the IDF and government have changed their hearts about it. Its coming out because the pressure from the UK, ICC and ICJ was getting too great to ignore. This would get Netanyahu, Gallant and the Chief of Staff in serious trouble. So they finally said the truth. That Israel is routinely torturing inmates. That sexual abuse is fairly common there. That people have been tortured to death.

Worst of all, many of the people in this facility were innocent. Rounded up by accident. But there was no real verification process before they were subjected to this hell on earth. This can’t go on.”

Utter crap and you’re lying in this comment.

This was my comment: "This is a bizarre timeline when we have a member of the Knesset arguing in defense of sodomizing non-Jews."

Hanoch Milwidsky is a member of the Knesset of Likud, and has been as of 2022.

During a recent meeting (televised, and caught on video), when talking about the matter of soldiers being arrested at the detention center, someone asked if it was legitimate "to insert a stick into a person’s rectum?”

His rather fiery answer was "Yes! If he is a Nukhba, everything is legitimate to do! Everything!"

I don't know about you, but that sounds like he's arguing in favor sodomizing non-Jews. (A particular kind of non-Jew, to be sure, but a non-Jew nonetheless.)

I’d ask you why you post this crap, but that’s obvious.

Because I find sodomy to be heinous.

For a member of the party representing a majority of the government faction in their parliament (said party being the one Netanyahu belongs to) to try and justify it is even more so.

For those who profess to belong to God's Chosen People to say sodomy is ever justifiable (when God destroyed Sodom for it!) is heinous to a degree that is utterly malevolent.

“ This was my comment: “This is a bizarre timeline when we have a member of the Knesset arguing in defense of sodomizing non-Jews.””

That’s right.

I read the article you posted and this comment is a lie.

Look, you hate Jews, obviously.

Look, you hate Jews, obviously.

1) That does not follow from anything I've stated or posted. (But you know that.)

2) Why are you trying to distract from the fact that a Likud member quite vocally professed that sodomy is justifiable? (Because you know it's not justifiable, and are trying to invoke the "anti-semite" flag to cover for it.)

You’re lying scum.

You wrote:

“ a member of the Knesset arguing in defense of sodomizing non-Jews.”

When the statement specifically addressed Nukhba. Not “non-Jews.”

“ Lawmaker Hanoch Milwidsky was asked as he defended the alleged abuse whether it was legitimate, “to insert a stick into a person’s rectum?”

“Yes!” he shouted in reply to his fellow parliamentarian. “If he is a Nukhba [Hamas militant], everything is legitimate to do! Everything!””

What is Nukhba?

Nukhba (Arabic: نخبة, lit. ‘elite’), Nukhba Force or Al-Nukhba are naval commandos[2] in a special forces unit of the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades, the military wing of Hamas.[3]

You’re lying scum.

A Nukhba is a non-Jew, so my statement was not false (your outraged pretensions to the contrary).

Why are you trying to defend a Knesset parliamentarian who loudly professed that it's justifiable for his country's soldiers to sodomize detained prisoners?

Give it up. You lie, you propagandize.

Why would I give up anything? I have not lied, and you are the one propagandizing in an attempt to defend the morally indefensible.

Maybe you should spend time with the various Jews who are (rightly) outraged by Hanoch Milwdisky's heinous professions regarding sodomy.

“ a member of the Knesset arguing in defense of sodomizing non-Jews.”

An overt lie claiming this person claimed the right to do this to any or all non-Jews.

Quite consistent with the methodology and style of Islamo and anti-Semitic propaganda.

You’re not even smart enough to make it about his actual statement that it’s ok to do it if it’s Nukhba.

In your anti-Semitic zeal you have to make it about Jews and non-Jews.

An overt lie claiming this person claimed the right to do this to any or all non-Jews.

Even a casual overview of Hanoch Milwidsky's public comments (even before this event) shows that he's an overt Jewish supremacist.

Quite consistent with the methodology and style of Islamo and anti-Semitic propaganda.

Have you noticed me criticizing or lumping all Jews together with Mildwidsky? (You haven't, because there are plenty of Israeli Jews who are just as, if not more, outraged about his words than I am.)

You’re not even smart enough to make it about his actual statement that it’s ok to do it if it’s Nukhba.

I made an observation that we live in a bizarre world where we have a Knesset member (true) publicly arguing that sodomizing non-Jews (not false) was justifiable (no lie detected).

(Pro-tip: prisoners who belong to Hamas also don't deserve to be sodomized.)

In your anti-Semitic zeal you have to make it about Jews and non-Jews.

Where have I criticized any Jew other than the Knesset member in question?

(Still wondering why you're defending someone trying to justify sodomy against anyone.)

So now you’re backing off when called out. At least you have some reason and perhaps integrity.

???

I've 'backed off' from quite literally nothing.

You appear to have imagined that I started with 'total Jew-hating anti-Semitism' and "backed off" to criticizing a single Knesset member...when that's what I've been doing this entire thread.

Are you okay?

You backed off by beginning to address the specific persons and context rather than your broad innuendo that the Israeli Parliament believes it is ok to do this to “non-Jews.”

Are you for real?

Go back to post #1: "This is a bizarre timeline when we have a member of the Knesset arguing in defense of sodomizing non-Jews."

"a member of the Knesset"

"a member"

Singular, as in one; not the entire Knesset; not multiple members; not a small group of members.

One.

You seem to have gaslit yourself into believing that ever I implied the Knesset in general was onboard the "sodomy train", when my comments ever only focused on the one guy.

And he was not saying it’s ok to do this to any non-Jew, correct?

I can't believe what I'm reading.

Why are you trying to weasel out a defense for this politician's justification for sodomy?

I don't care who the intended target is: sodomy is sodomy!

What is wrong with you?

Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.