If the rule is unfair, it should be overturned. However, I do see many disadvantages in giving inexperienced athletes too much power in this area as well. The majority of college athletes don’t go pro and giving them too much right now would hurt their scholastic future, imo.
Although I realize that college athleticism is more pro in today’s world anyway.
This is going to bring about the end of major college sports as you know it. The NCAA is a big-money racket anyway, so that’s not a bad thing.