Posted on 01/03/2022 7:43:15 AM PST by SJackson
Daniel Greenfield, a Shillman Journalism Fellow at the Freedom Center, is an investigative journalist and writer focusing on the radical Left and Islamic terrorism.
It’s not just Elizabeth Warren.
America has a huge “Fake Indian” problem. It’s hard to know exactly how many people, often white leftists, falsely claim to be descended from the nation’s early Indian population, but census numbers show either a massive population boom or a sharp growth in fake Indians.
According to the 2010 census, there were 2.9 million American Indians and Alaskans, and another 2.3 million who claimed to be a combination of Indians and another race or races.
The 2020 census however shows that 3.7 million claimed to be American Indians or Alaskans, and another 5.9 million described themselves as part Indian.
5.2 million to 9.7 million is an 86.5% rise. And going from 4.1 million in 2000 to 5.2 million in 2010 and then almost 10 million suggests that what we’re seeing here is not a natural increase that happened through a baby boom.
“Why the jump in the Native American population may be one of the hardest to explain,” CNN shrugged.
But the Census Bureau provides a simple explanation, “The American Indian and Alaska Native alone population grew by 27.1%, and the American Indian and Alaska Native in combination population grew by 160% since 2010.”
The biggest growth happened when the 2.3 million people who claimed to be part Indian in 2010 jumped to 5.9 million in 2020. That 3.6 million increase is responsible for the staggering growth.
While identity politics activists have claimed that the Census Bureau was undercounting the American Indian population on reservations, that’s not where the real growth is coming from.
The question of who is an Indian when it comes to the tribes is a fraught issue. Some tribes have attempted to preserve their population integrity with blood quantum requirements and documented evidence of ancestry, while others have thrown open the door to everyone. There have also been legal battles over the dubious move to count the descendants of former black slaves who belonged to members of Indian tribes as being enrolled in those tribes.
Some tribes are legitimate peoples while others are little more than legal fictions with white leaders who act as fronts for international gaming interests and shadowy corporations.
The membership rolls of even most legitimate tribes can grow a lot when money is on the table.
The Navajos boasted that they had reached 400,000 members, but an Associated Press story noted that, "Navajos also saw an enrollment increase as the tribe offered hardship assistance payments from last year’s federal Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act, boosting the tribe’s rolls from about 306,000 to nearly 400,000 citizens.”
The Cherokee Nation shot up from 360,589 in 2018 to an alleged 400,000 now. Even media accounts conceded that "there was a significant increase in applications after Principal Chief Chuck Hoskin Jr. announced $2,000 COVID-19 assistance payments to enrolled Cherokee citizens as well as people approved for citizenship in the tribal nation by June 2022."
But most of the growth in the American Indian population is not coming from the tribes.
Who are the "new" Indians?
The 2010 Census Bureau numbers showed that 63% of the mixed race population "identified as American Indian and Alaska Native and White." In other words, more Elizabeth Warrens.
A percentage of Americans, especially in states like Oklahoma, have rightly or wrongly claimed Indian ancestry, but the striking growth in recent years is not the natural result of old family legends, but wokeness and career development based around affirmative action.
White people face growing discrimination in applying for college or looking for work. And for the new generation there is much less shame and fewer taboos around lying about race. Anecdotally, the number of millennials and zoomers who falsely claim to be black, Latino, Jewish, or members of any other minority group, has exploded according to employers.
Elizabeth Warren may have been a pioneer, but the number of fake Indians is growing sharply.
One author, Circe Sturm, an anthropology professor at the University of Texas at Austin, theorizes in her book, “Becoming Indian", that the explosive population growth among the American Indian population is actually driven by white people who are "fleeing whiteness".
But the fake Indians, like Senator Elizabeth Warren, aren't fleeing whiteness so much as they're exploiting a racist attack on white people that they've stirred up to profit from a minority identity.
And even setting up fake tribes.
Strum writes, "The number of these new self-identified tribes is startling. Over the course of my research, I discovered 253 groups scattered across the U.S. that identify as some sort of Cherokee tribe. This is a huge number considering that there are only 573 federally recognized tribes, three of which are Cherokee."
American Indian tribes have been fighting a rearguard campaign against fake Indians, but it’s one that they are likely to lose as the Left embraces fake Indian activists who are happy to put their fake identities at the service of their political causes.
The fake Indian problem is not unique to America.
The exposure of Carrie Bourassa in Canada, after she appeared in Indian garb and blamed systemic racism, was a major scandal in that country. Even more absurdly, Australia’s “white aborigines”, leftist academics, often blonde and blue-eyed, who claim special status and privileges because of their alleged aboriginal status, are a longstanding problem.
But the rapid growth of America’s fake Indian problem suggests we’re heading for a crisis.
Indian tribes enjoy a unique legal status that has conferred significant economic and political benefits. The replacement and displacement of the tribal populations by a new activist base entirely dedicated to radical leftist politics would be a new Trail of Tears, but also quite dangerous. And yet it’s a crisis that’s been coming since the American Indian Movement.
Between 2010 and 2020, the number of part Indians went from a minority to a majority of the American Indian population. If this trend continues, the vast number of people who build careers and public identities around being American Indians will be fake Indians.
America’s fake Indians already outnumber real Indians. And it’s only getting worse.
My late wife’s kin has lots of provable Cherokee in their background.
The family claim that I had Cherokee in my background proved to be wishful thinking. that person was a German-Italian orphan from Chicago.
Yeah, that is my families oral history as well. Funny thing is that when my sister actually put the work into doing a genealogy trace, no Indians showed up.
Did find a family member who fought in the Revolutionary War but spent most of his time on a prison ship.
Thanks for the Greenfield ping.
Ancestory DNA testing shows I have 8% Native American from my father, He probably had 16 % but did not have dna testing at that time in his life. He always knew his mother was part Nanimo (Vancouver Island reservation) but when he tried to prove it (to garner some special fishing rights) he was unable to. His mom looked very indian, but passed as white and once she married and moved to the US, at age 16, she never put Native American on any records. It was common to avoid discrimination by doing this.
One time in Washington state on business a person came up to me and asked if I was part indian. I was surprised but also proud that I had some indian resemblence.
My Canadian great-grandfather was Métis, with some Ojibwa blood mixed in with the French and Scottish. After the failed Métis “rebellion”, he picked up his family and moved south into Minnesota and Wisconsin.
I’ve never claimed the ancestry to use it to get a position in a law school or for any other benefit or recognition.
In the 90s I used to drive through the Poospatuck reservation in Mastic, LI, NY to by smokes. It was like driving through west Harlem without the tenements.
My ancestors on both sides have been traced back 1640 when they settled in Massachusetts. This was over 130 years before the United States was declared a nation. Does that make me a Native American?
Lots of us would love to collect our share on the Irish Potato famine pity party - and how awful the poor Irish refugees were treated in the United States... but that TIME HAS PASSED.
Irish would be jerks - and a poor excuses for citizens - if they were allowed to milk a terror for personal gain - a terror they never experienced.
Should be the same for all groups... I'm guessing 90 years tops from the time of true victimization.
Past that and it's taking the system and damaging innocent people who had no part in the victimization. In short - the point where 'the victims' transition and become the 'new thugs'...
Why not pretend to be Indian? Whites are hated, reviled, vilified, condemned and blamed for all the evils in the world. Why not join a group that gets special privileges and gain instant moral superiority?
If you’re born here you are native to America, hence Native American.
My family is a mix of AniYunWiya and Scots/Irish....
In other words, we are drunk Indians...
Reminds me of the Tonto Kowalski joke.
I have travelled (in the US - I’m too scared to go anywhere else except maybe Canada) quite a bit. Even moreso I’ve studied history alot so it’s doubly perplexing. Though I’d like to have a good summary history of Indians in NA. Not the PC kind, but the real kind.
Bingo. One the the 2 reasons I will never use that nomenclature.
Well, I was just going by your comment:
“...It just never seemed anywhere, outside maybe my husbands home in central PA, that there was much of anything to look at...”
Maybe it just doesn’t take a lot to interest me, but I’ve found a great deal of things to look at, things to do, and places that I’ll always remember from my travels in the USA, not to mention military time in other parts of the world...
Actually the Irish are the original pity-party group in the US. Indeed they suffered to some extent due to British rule. Meanwhile, they ran gangs and New York City itself, Boss Tweed and Tammany Hall, and have the nerve to claim they were so oppressed. Nonsense, all of it. Nevermind the entertainment over the decades (not simply now - much earlier) extolling them as if they’re the greatest bunch ever, and getting a holiday here.
Just like the black millionaires playing a child’s game claiming victimhood - in the here and now.
But yeah, I get your point. But that’s a big peeve of mine.
My Mother told me I was part gypsy and part Indian. She also told me that my father was Man A but I was partially raised by Man B. I have nearly black hair and green eyes.
FrogDad has blue eyes and strawberry blond head hair with red body hair. Spicy food always breaks him out in a sweat. I’ve always referred to him as my “Nordic God”.
So a couple of years ago we did an Ancestry test.
ALL of my ancestry is from Ireland, England and Norway. My father was Man C. :p
FrogDad’s ancestry is from Germany and England.
LOL. I’m more Nordic than he is! This was interesting stuff.
Well, I was specifically referring to Indian sites. Those that actually have some “tourist” value because they’re obvious enough.
I’m the kind that picks at every tiny bit of wreckage (maybe it really was exactly that!) and beer cans and wonders what this site was. Old stonework and pieces of fence hidden in the woods. Forensics. Nevermind my devotion to graveyards - which also drew me to Ft. Shantok. New England is great for ancient, readable graveyards.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.