Posted on 03/03/2021 6:31:30 AM PST by Kaslin
Granting amnesty – and, eventually, U.S. citizenship – to almost 15 million illegal aliens will be a win-win for everybody, argue the policy’s cheerleaders. Former illegal aliens will “come out of the shadows,” and Americans will become a more compassionate and richer society, both economically and culturally. We are expected to believe that there will be no significant costs, losers, or trade-offs. That is a rosy vision indeed, but, unfortunately, amnesty is unlikely to lessen socio-economic inequality – a problem president Biden said he wants to remedy. It may, in fact, lead to increased class and ethnic tensions.
A moderate amount of income inequality is necessary. If everyone gets the same outcome, why study or work hard? But too much income inequality can be a bad thing too. It exacerbates the resentment of the have-nots (or have-littles) against the haves – particularly if the former perceive the system as rigged against them – thereby undermining and weakening an already fraying national and social cohesion.
Illegal aliens generally lag behind both native-born Americans and legal immigrants in terms of educational attainment and skills (this has changed only very slightly in recent years, but the main point stands). As FAIR’s recent study of the history of amnesty points out, “the average illegal alien household earns $36,000 per year – far less than what the average household headed by a citizen or lawful migrant earns. This means that most illegal aliens would qualify for state and federal welfare programs if an amnesty is implemented.”
Thus, amnesty would be a factor unnecessarily exacerbating income inequality by suddenly adding on millions of additional low-income, welfare-dependent individuals, thereby expanding the bottom of our social pyramid (yes, the illegal aliens were living and working in the U.S. before, but they were not part of the legal American community). Also keep in mind that amnesty will likely encourage more illegal migration – as happened after the 1986 amnesty – in the hopes of benefiting from a future amnesty, i.e., more individuals entering the U.S. who lack both the education and skills to succeed in a 21st century economy.
This means a greater fiscal burden on a shrinking American middle- and working-class either in the form of higher taxes or (most likely) even more debt. Furthermore, adding millions of amnestied people to the legal workforce will mainly benefit wealthy employers who will have even less incentive to raise wages.
The proponents of amnesty would have us believe that, if only they were given “documents,” illegal aliens, or at least their children, would rapidly rise to the top. True, many will probably earn more in the legal economy, but they are also likely to continue working poorly-remunerated, lower-skilled jobs. Hence, a lion’s share of the fruits of whatever economic expansion and job creation may result from amnesty will probably accrue to employers and investors.
Moreover, as Reihan Salam reminds us in his insightful book (Melting Pot or Civil War?), the kids of low-skilled and poorly-educated immigrants sadly all too often tend to inherit their parents’ position towards the bottom of the socio-economic pyramid. Salam warns that we should “worry about the children they raise on American soil, and what will happen to our society if impoverished immigrants give rise to an impoverished second generation that has no memory of life in the old country and who won’t tolerate being relegated to second-class status.”
As amnestied former illegal aliens – as well as many legal immigrants and working-class minorities – find upward mobility increasingly difficult, class and ethnic bitterness will likely grow and intensify, aggravating social divisions.
Those who acknowledge the problematic nature of excessive income inequality, but simultaneously support mass amnesty, should recognize that amnesty will do nothing to decrease income inequality. And the profits-first corporate types, who view amnesty mainly through the prism of keeping down labor costs, need to look at the big picture and consider that income-inequality-exacerbated class and ethnic conflict is less, not more, conducive to business.
It's not 11 million or 15 million, more likely closer to 30-50 million. There are at 15 million in California alone.
And, family re-unification too so Biden will fly in 90 relatives for each one - and hand them voter registration cards before they get here.
Yes please come to our country illegally, break our laws by just entering. Then we will give you things most American Citizens can’t even qualify for. You will make everyone so much happier and it will be rainbows and unicorns for all.
Give them 100 acres of Government lands and a mule and take away the welfare checks.
Amnesty will be the Final nail in the coffin for the Middle Class.
I do not expect the income of someone more skilled or better educated than I. Why would anyone else? Income inequality is liberal word salad.
OMG, how many things can be wrong in one sentence fragment?
First of all, social and economic inequality exist because inequality exists. It is a component of human biology. It is neither fortunate or unfortunate. It simply IS.
Therefore, the inability of schemes to change this cannot be "unfortunate".
And as far as what "President Biden says"?
C'MON, MAN!
Correct it is at least triple the number they are gaslighting us with.
Probably more like 40-50 million.
If all of them had the same military uniform on, we’d look like an occupied nation.
The Deplorables want a Comprehensive Immigration Enforcement bill, missing since 1986 ONE TIME amnesty. Since that amnesty was granted already, a second amnesty is off the table. What remains is the enforcement the Democrats have disallowed since then.
The List of Comprehensive Immigration Enforcement, missing since 1986 goes like this -
1) southern barrier;
2) require eVerify to hire;
3) end all chain migration;
4) birthright per Minor v. Happersett (plural parents);
5) end work visas;
6) 10-year moratorium on all new applications for citizenship (40 years to allow workplace automation effects on downsizing population);
7) Set up an illegal aliens’ victim restitution fund.
Enactment of these provisions will motivate illegal aliens to SELF-deport, and remove colonizadors from our welfare rolls.
Employment laws state that NONE of them should be holding ANY job.
Amnesty is a gift to the cartels body hustling business and more MS13 members wonder if any DC. hacks getting a little freezer money on the deal?.
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.